The Tenth Meeting of the Opposition Coordination Council

Mr. Duncan, I would suggest asking.

mixed-race woman

your position on the problems that are coming in

which, because this is the very problem

which is now

[music]

no objections, it will help

and could a request be made to the church, help with these 50

delete 10 works, I

must

a little

[music]

this

what I am saying does not mean

[music]

does not work

and can I do it this way.

thank you

respected members

of the council

in recent days, when I really closely

became acquainted with what tasks

lie ahead, I began to have doubts, and now

I will share

my doubts

were taking place

the council, I

have been dealing for a very long time, for more than 20 years, with

what happens in elections in Russia

our political orientation

you will agree that

right now this has twisted into a state there

when money, accordingly, the person

appointment is written in Article 3

of Article 32 of the Constitution

-stration

in the future, I

agreed to the proposal

the problem now

I am studying

how

which

[music]

thank you

December

2013

not in the format of a criterion

a person to this

completely impossible, and open ones are not

constructive, therefore

apparently we need to come up with some

other mechanisms

for nominating candidates, restrictions

of advancement somewhere, in principle, are not

invented naturally

in political systems, and political

party systems of civil society

were born naturally, and not by way of

building from blocks inside one of the

offices on Staraya Square (the area in Moscow associated with the Russian presidential administration)

is resolved by means of the social system, was

the nomination of candidates was organized by way of

but mainly, though not only mainly

through organized groups of people who

already had their own political views; this is, first of all,

first of all

party, but captured the system

was created in an artificial sense, therefore

we cannot now go so far as to

for example, conduct under a party system

completely, completely conduct elections by

the party system; by the way, I think this applies to

all elections in Russia

to the Opposition Coordination Council, I

believe that this applies to whatever actually

exists in Russia

more pleasant

associations of citizens, not necessarily

formally registered, naturally; perhaps

these are, first and foremost, unregistered

you understand for what reasons they may

refuse to register us

unite, and nevertheless

a proportional system

creates obstacles

which are completely unknown; it

welcomes being made up of people consisting

half of

media figures, because they are constantly on

television, and

unknown people

in the end do not allow, within

the body, from such a body to make

certain

decisions; because of this, by the way, there arise

all sorts of exclusionary barriers and so

on

well, to a greater extent now we need to

lean, in these elections,

toward a proportional system for nominating

candidates from already well-known

also from local associations; once again

I repeat, naturally it is absolutely

not necessary for them to be formally registered

existing and well-known associations

the question

whether there should be a procedure for the movement itself

the provocation council is not entirely clear to me

because there is also the question

of ideal representation, and I very much

hope that the Coordination Council

of the opposition

is a nationwide body, because so far

Russia has not yet fallen apart into pieces

and

so, as I understand it, we must create

the Coordination Council as

something that should be created within Russia as a whole

taking everything and participation into account, therefore the question

of territory, which, by the way,

to connect, we lived, then first of all them

must also be resolved by the system, but there

is a proportional system, you know

there are also certain devices that allow

the territorial issue to be resolved; this is

division into territorial

regional list groups; all of this

will have to be resolved, and this

let's have a drink, the work that is supposed to receive

an absolutely assessment, bring together my acquaintances

I consider the most

the least known in this respect are

three people who

are not experts on issues

of electoral systems, first of all

Arkady Finch Lyukov, secondly

Oleg Nikolaevich Koldunov, thirdly

Alexei, holding a pen, not

possible garden, I forgot to mention

it seems to me that these are the three main

specialists in electoral systems in

Russia

in general, on electoral systems, and I

hope they can be brought in, but

at least Arkady Film Che I have already

brought in

issues that were resolved

to this rather complicated issue

the issue of nomination and registration

of candidates

the third problem that concerns me

it is purely of a personal nature, do not

think that I am asking for myself to be paid

that's the difference

all right, I won't say, and a remarkable

fact—the next story about the city

election commission, I'll tell

so the question is this: this activity

as I understand it, this is a huge undertaking

of work; if we have 60 so far

last year in the regional election

committees, 160 regional election

committees—that is one and a half times more than

for example, the Golos organization had

regional branches

which, as is known, worked with foreign

grants, and still, there were

at least ten people

making up the central core who

worked from morning till night; what is needed is

a staff apparatus for this business, and

some people are willing to join the

staff, but as I understand it, the staff

needs to be paid, but this is a kind of

another minor problem

the fourth problem that arose right here

spontaneously in connection with the fact that to me

representatives of two groups came up and

said that 200 are needed

representatives; let's say this is

of ideological currents; this is also

a problem for me, I believe that

I do not rule out, at least, that in the

capacity of voting members in the

central election committee there should not

be representatives of

ideological currents

I do not rule out that there should instead be

representatives of those

organizations that will

that have nominated

candidates, with заранее established

representation

for ideological groups, but of course all this

will be decided in the proper way

by the way

such a system

for the composition of the election commission existed at

the elections to the Constituent Assembly in 1917

when

the electoral committee elected to the central

election commission for the elections

to the Constituent Assembly; it in fact

consisted of a certain core and members

those who were nominated

[music]

by the parties that participated in those

elections, and

the last thing I want to say: I am absolutely

sure that right now we are not yet ready

to hold elections to the Coordinating Council

it is necessary that

the initial working group prepare everything

anew, in fact prepare it—well, not

entirely anew, after all, and as I

said, very good documents were

drawn up last year on the basis of those

documents; taking these documents into account

a new election regulation should be prepared

apparently, first of all, what must change is

the electoral system itself in the narrow

sense of the word that I was talking about, and so

it is necessary

it seems to me that authority should be given to the

supreme working group to prepare all

these provisions

and submit them for discussion

at a meeting of the Coordinating Council

in the end, the Coordinating Council

of the opposition

must approve these in some form

provisions, because it makes the

final decision

despite the fact that in itself

the central election committee is

independent of the Coordinating Council

of the opposition and of its members personally

bodies, and I will not declare—let him

this view, like Vladimir... damn, I blurted it out

ornately... also somehow managed supplies

when he was elected chairman of the central

notable central election

commission, he said that the first law is

"Putin is always right"—I will not say that the first

law is that in war, or someone sees

always

it happens

the provision is that what we are doing should be

with the expert council

discussed by the expert council, and I will review

the documents; and second, it is apparently necessary

to create a monetary fund for

payment

to pay the staff of the central election

commission

please speak

How are you?

I'm listening, sent.

No way to give it a run.

The soldier sat down, so the amount is one million rubles.

Payment, payment.

[music]

I can't say right now.

I understood what to take out in the game.

Question.

Impossible, we won't have enough.

There won't be enough time to.

To do it—you understand that right now...

A huge effort, including by me, traditionally.

Couture oil widely electoral.

Of the election commissions of the 21st regiment for the elections in Moscow.

Moscow, I think.

The main visible work will be carried out.

Survey.

[music]

Moscow.

[music]

[laughter]

Lina Medina.

Purely in terms of organizing our world by weight.

And a question, a proposal.

There is no reader right now.

Of the current session and the court, clearly on...

For which there is also no code yet, and no guests so far.

Tourist, what is the status at the start of our meeting?

Since, as we can see, for now we currently...

A full-scale session.

It turns out Korean—we can be there together.

A meeting of members, traditionally, of this council.

It can be done afterward so that...

So the process goes normally—maybe take...

Just our chair is ready.

The meeting that is going on now—it doesn't matter.

How long it will last, in order to...

Simply all our procedures, which...

That we traditionally apply according to this vision.

Of ours were observed accordingly.

Providing an opportunity for...

Remarks, questions, answers, and so on.

And so on.

Colleagues refer to colleagues themselves.

To the representatives for, in our time...

A proposal for the meeting—Katya, hands, work.

To appoint as chair was...

In advance, rocky.

If.

Earlier.

In that case, I propose...

Konstantin.

There is a traditional member, k-tional.

Gisborne—this is people's responsibility, their own.

The duties that we will have to carry out.

35 and.

Meeting of members.

Of the council.

Listened.

Summer adventures.

If, however, it raised the issue that such a decision...

Has been adopted, but if such a decision causes concern...

Then, although this is somewhat unexpected, taking into account...

Such a decision—it's just that we have underway...

Accordingly, in accordance with that...

The proposal, the product of which...

The conduct of the session is taking place.

Functions, but...

He opened, for example, to the chair, essentially.

The vote came up, so MMG and...

To send, in fact, for... nothing.

The rest, and for two, insignificant.

Problem.

Can it be resolved without giving...

No.

At one's own discretion.

They adopt.

[music]

Total decisions.

Normal, but...

Considered generally arbitrary.

Rule.

To questions.

36.

Central Committee.

Has developed some kind of algorithm.

By section, this is...

Automatically, automatically.

[music]

They.

Your current understanding of those...

Problems facing Gagarin.

[music]

Of the next post on the screen of the Savan website.

Realistically assessing.

Which stand.

[music]

Mystical.

Maybe you will [address] them in the second half of November.

No earlier.

Than the time when candidate nominations begin, and...

The start of registration.

I think that should happen.

[music]

[music]

Question.

To entrust this decision.

Simply a matter of legal drafting, it...

[music]

Have taken it on themselves, ready for such...

Story.

Perfectly, as I understand it.

[music]

[music]

Situation.

Nature.

Compensate.

To speak as much as possible about humanism and...

[music]

A crime that is too large-scale.

A large number—Arbat.

[music]

Africa.

Shops.

There it is—the power.

Attention.

Where?

[music]

Russian gas and

violation

permission

only from a political point of view, in order to

during the demonstration

constructiveness

simply.

[music]

who committed crimes

206

show

in fact, this crime did not exist

would

[music]

resources, how to protect

[music]

with you anymore

the impression that the fear is already out on the streets

can include hyperlinks to

the relevant articles, and in essence one can

it will be possible to hand over, to ask, meaning this is not something

it, if this causes harm, three times rotation

usually happens

projects

[music]

we didn't manage to prepare a new one in time, of course

it is good when it comes to roads.

now here

[music]

real

[music]

help

18

theoretically, although some of us at that

stage

objectively

magical

whether by an evil act, ending, deciding

I recommend the traditional approach

we add

[music]

very strongly

[music]

the percentage of Germans wants no

special survey

I take the position of the mayor of Moscow and

unfortunately

since things are not usual for us right now

meetings at the end of summer, only a conference for everyone

take shelter with us

decision

[music]

the following relation to your activities

especially

[music]

stood out specifically

of course, it is best to hold the discussion

of this issue in the presence of—I very much

hope that you, the panel this evening,

covering them closely in the campaign, will be able to convey

in as much detail as possible, and

the discussion of which

will take place here

it seems, in words, the situation is clear, it

needs the mass media

information, members, besides, it promises sleep to

it is important to record several

positions

is that it is the so-called

from the very moment of its, their announcement until

the strongest point, including the events

of the day before yesterday and yesterday

an entirely rubber-stamp operation

with the current guests

therefore

participation of members

Carmen, airplane, salute, and representatives

from the opposition

special, specific guarantees

carried out by the authorities, one can understand that

what that is, and what consequences

it will have for the people themselves, teaching how in this

this is how the civic movement itself will be

of this special operation, as now

is quite obviously

legitimization

maximum legitimate hook, honestly

the election in Moscow

the lack of a sufficient number of

yes, yes, including candidates on the hook

from the opposition

the official number of participants

[music]

in Moscow may seem so off the mark

that although the current sides si en el bulli

the winner, but this will not be sufficiently

convincing

residents of the city of Moscow and certain outside

observers

at the very least, the task is to

maximize the number of thousands

of participants in these blows, in one way or for

it, by methods that we are observing

recently, with all the various

twists, especially this

3

aspirations

is performed by the so-called municipal

filter

an illegitimate moment that was in

the past year, with the help of which, as

we understand it, 40 potential candidates

sea 3, in four people were

screened out using a procedural panel

procedure, as a result only carry out

now, even by the standards of the current

legislation, is illegitimate

operation, because these elections are

completely honest and fair

not competitive

elections in which the forming

majority of potential participants, 85

percent, were cut out artificially

by artificial means, therefore these

candidates who

are registered now

continues or intends to continue

participation in the operation must be

perfected; legitimate ones suffered

history

geographical elections, and thus

participation in such an operation, in such elections, became more frequent

this follows from these, and thus a refusal

one of the demands over which, in December

in 2011 and March 2012, in our cities

tens and hundreds of thousands of our

fellow citizens came out demanding fair

competitors be elected

and the latest action took place in an extremely

unpleasant way; an additional issue is immigration

of a legitimate municipal [candidate] for Viktor

moreover, hundreds of houses with the help of whom, with

with the help of a check, Warsaw, quickly so-called

the municipal [system] was flooded in a completely un

you know, this literally says

the municipal filter

filter

distribution

of votes by members of United Russia in the elected

selectively chosen as a candidate for these

elections, and as a result the municipal

filter, which at no other moment was

used, became a means of legitimization from

the side of not only

the side of those people who

called and considered themselves part of the opposition

the next point

it seems that I can guess

the motivation, in particular that of Navalny

when this operation is undertaken in order to

possibly

in a certain way expose

his own situation, to change his

status, including in order to

strengthen the status he already has now

as someone regarded as persecuted for

political motives

the status of a person who now, after

the announcement of the verdict against them there

has obviously become

not yet fully, judging by the signs, though we still cannot

yet move to this alternating status of

a political prisoner in these circumstances

we are dealing with the fate of one person

thus nothing is capable of drawing even more

attention, even among our

fellow citizens, on the one hand and on the other

hand, a substantial and radical

mass deterioration in the general conditions for conducting

opposition and protest activity

activity aimed at creating

stable institutions of a free

democratic society

I understand that in this situation, for those who

made their decision, that decision series does not

turn out by itself; we must understand that

in our situation as well

communication has improved substantially, and it is necessary

to restore momentum for our actions

it is impossible not to mention

that

the recent actions

of this campaign and success

of the opposition movement

connected with participation in this special

will become more obvious to you

for tens and hundreds of thousands of our

supporters

of the democratic movement; on the one hand, this

was a doubtful plus, a plus that

strategic

the strategy of the opposition protest

movement should not be the one that

has been proposed now, and to which people so

readily responded, and on that scale

I would not say

despite all attempts

to tie the Coordinating Council to

the broader history of the Russian opposition's stance toward

supporting one or another candidate during

the campaign

the decision of the Coordinating Council—you cannot deceive

anyone about it

from the campaign; right now we do not have

the Council has a certain

degree of freedom

to act on behalf of

to adopt a more subtle strategy, because

in order to build a truly free

democratic

society in our country

?

Any questions?

[music]

substantial

tactics and strategy

of protest activity

of the country

the decision of 25 members of the council

to put forward as the single candidate in

these elections, Alexei

that you have no decision that is absolutely your own

no, you probably do not have such obvious grounds for that decision over us

obvious grounds to begin whatever you please

in any case, in what way

participation

.

how are they different from real elections?

[music]

construction

I will sell

[music]

I would like to draw your attention to the fact that

we have already considered

[music]

[music]

could you calculate the decision regarding

the issue

this decision was voted for by

the majority

of the information union, 25

not to return to resolving this problem

it's just that this topic

for me, the goal is to gather and then, at the level of our

positions, it is pointless, I understand

not

agree

collector, please

leaves

or

reputation

if

a small part

[music]

now

about the company

[music]

since

narrowing at

to work with this correctly, let us return to

the public mood

religion has already asked for these sheets with

an amendment to the needles, but like the others

in the little grove, in fact, does not throw away

you understand, to study it, because this issue

will be introduced again; I hope it will be

considered when the amendment takes shape

these are aimed at eliminating

contradictions that currently

the regulations contain the elimination of

contradictions, first, and improving the norms from

our point of view, second; and the third goal

of the stage is simply dramatic, in fact 6

importance

attention

[music]

[music]

I apologize

it seemed that one's own and someone else's

[music]

in cash

[music]

very large

in general, state policy, one way or another

includes relations with

various religious organizations

[music]

the final alignment between

the games of a huge organization for

carrying out

interaction and diplomatic attachés

so decent ones going beyond the bounds

of the zone of what, it seems to me, is unfounded

I see quite enough such moments in Zurich

[music]

this means that

the meeting... canciones de... let us make it interesting

a substantive discussion, as

wherever we may be with them now, naturally

character

we will see, and accordingly above, which

is inflicted on the democratic

opposition movement by the actions of

some of our colleagues

above

[music]

[music]

[music]

support

[music]

in the middle

on someone specific

ask you

[music]

did not remove the doubt about the need and

granting the status of political

included

further, as relations with risk and

[music]

oppositional in general

[music]

supports or

which

[music]

there is

a specific misunderstanding up to 100

of the characters

of the list, juice

[music]

.

[music]

enter

clip art

published

pages from Kvachkov's notebook

which, according to this model, highly

evidence in court

honor

looked like lists of people ordered

prepared to try obesity after

success

number 3, which

Klochkov

according to the investigation, planned

Alberti of the defense, if I understand correctly

in droves; he was simply fantasizing

I am ready to ask: do you feel that

the council should be ready

to recognize Chekov as a political prisoner

who is planning, or are we simply

drawing up execution lists in their fantasies

lists

for a moment, I would like to ask Saladin

now, essentially

in order to

acquire the law absolutely that

a guilty verdict these days, well

more substantial

I already... who are you going to deal with

[music]

admission

[music]

[music]

his

changes in the situation

and

selection and every kind of support for this person

assistance, and soon, what is now

approaching and concluding

to what is happening, Milevsky, these types of

bonds which

makes real changes in

52 right after the last one

Ladies, you aptly said that he

is a person

who is prepared to use another secular

use of the regime; you were not speaking about

the secular—more precisely, the regime with

agreed, and

then I believe that

if a person has acknowledged they are ready to use

GPS with a political prisoner, we open

a supplementary selection, and this is any

when any terrorist

therefore should somehow be recognized

as a political prisoner on the same

grounds.

Regarding Alexei Navalny, there came about

a process, if I am not mistaken, Jane, and for us

you will provide

it is known he spent 27 years in prison

[music]

[music]

[music]

direct participation in the preparation

of the administration, which

you

[music]

[music]

[music]

[music]

[music]

[music]

current

resources

drawing up the following list

of political prisoners and others drew attention

who

a large number

political

month

look

proposed not to treat these people according to

ideological criteria, and

compiled on ideological grounds, and

representatives

of the nationalist faction took the trouble

also, at times, to look into cases

that may possibly have a political dimension

[music]

of the accused, or who are

representatives of some Caucasian

ethnicity; I think that would be simpler

to consider in a comprehensive way and review

held the proposed

I

know

the situation

his appeal to the president

operation

[music]

[music]

on

[music]

decision

a civilized, modern way

[music]

[music]

during the hearing

woman

they were convicted; it was not simply that there was no

vessel

for Archer when clearing their territory

anime; at first they called for

if on

remote

revived, transported

metal

society there, across the sky, thickness

this is his team in Moscow.

Shablykino

used agronomic, possibly

gifted part

having placed

I

for now only

hotel pattaya

[music]

[music]

[music]

purchases

food

with oneself

this

so

[music]

yes

[music]

and

[music]

and

[music]

I

[music]

by

but

across the ice

[music]

well

[music]

[music]