The newspaper describes a meeting between Moscow mayoral candidate Alexei Navalny and residents of the Losinoostrovsky District, held on August 14 at the Torfyanka Park, where about a hundred people came. Navalny discusses issues in healthcare, housing and utilities, and migration, citing examples such as long waits at clinics and demands for money for medical examinations. He also promises to push for transparency, the publication of data, and fair competitions when public funds are spent. A separate section claims that the current mayor, Sergei Sobyanin, avoids answering questions about the expensive apartments owned by his daughters. It provides details about the alleged cost of the housing and casts doubt on the source of the funds. Navalny links these issues to corruption and ineffective governance. The article ends with a call to vote for Navalny on September 8, 2013, followed by a list of his projects and achievements that his team cites.

Loading PDF...

1

/

0

Text version

NAVALNY

IN LOSINOOSTROVSKY

CANDIDATE PROFILE

“When I become mayor, I will act strictly according to the rules: if it says that a fair tender for metro construction must be held, then I will hold it. When Putin calls and asks me to give all the contracts to Timchenko, I will not do that.”

PAGE 4

RESIDENTS’ OPINIONS

“I believe in Alexei, I like his energy, charisma, and, of course, his productive work.”

PAGE 2

DADDY’S DAUGHTERS, OR JULPLOSHCHAD

PAGE 3

ON WEDNESDAY, AUGUST 14, A MEETING TOOK PLACE IN TORFYANKA PARK BETWEEN MOSCOW MAYORAL CANDIDATE ALEXEI NAVALNY AND RESIDENTS OF THE LOSINOOSTROVSKY DISTRICT

The meeting began at 1:00 p.m., in the middle of the workday, and gathered about a hundred people. Alexei has had twice as many, and more. But such a small audience is an excellent opportunity to speak more closely with voters and have time to answer all questions.

The problems Muscovites face are very similar: healthcare, housing and utilities, migrants. Navalny told those gathered that 20,000 rubles are allocated annually for outpatient care for each person. But in practice, the money is spent inefficiently, and the services are poor. People complain about long lines, a lack of specialists, and the need to travel to consultations in different parts of the city. Navalny explained that the money exists, but it is being stolen and distributed non-transparently.

Among the other topics were roads and urban improvement. Navalny noted that roads should be built by competent road construction organizations, not former “judo buddies,” and that tenders should be conducted transparently so that the winners are the best contractors, not companies close to those in power.

Alexei also spoke about the migration problem: in Moscow, according to him, there are too many illegal migrants, which creates additional problems for security and the labor market. He proposed strengthening oversight and tightening requirements for employers.

Participants asked a wide range of questions — from the repair of children's playgrounds to the operation of municipal polyclinics. Navalny answered them in detail, explaining the proposed changes and collecting specific examples of problems for further work with his team.

NAVALNY

RESIDENTS ABOUT THE MEETING

ROMAN, 45, ENTREPRENEUR:

“I live in this district, and I was interested to know what is happening here, maybe Alexei has some information about the head of the local administration — Kramar. I took part in the city duma elections and saw how they take place and how the head of the administration influences all participation in them. Kramar works exclusively in his own interests. For example, there are no toilets in this park, although this is an extremely necessary little thing. I believe in Alexei, I like his energy, charisma and, of course, productive work.”

POLINA PETROVNA, PENSIONER:

“I like Navalny: he is a handsome, intelligent person. I see that he is educated and will pay attention to education, which I would very much like, because nothing is more important than education. An educated person can do without a doctor, but a doctor without an educated person — no! I believe in Navalny. If a person is illiterate, he cannot solve anything, but an educated person tries to change and develop. I like that Alexei is not afraid to go to such meetings. I support him!”

THE MOSCOW MAYORAL ELECTION WILL TAKE PLACE ON SUNDAY, SEPTEMBER 8, 2013, FROM 8:00 TO 20:00. YOUR CANDIDATE — ALEXEI NAVALNY

NOTHING IS IMPOSSIBLE

“How are you going to solve all this?” asks an elderly man in a cap. “What exactly interests you?” Alexei уточняет. “Everything?” says the man. “Let's take people who are waiting their turn to receive an apartment. There are about 400 thousand of them in Moscow. And where can one see this queue? Why has it still not been published in order to prevent all scandals, although this is elementary to do? If I become mayor, I will definitely open this information for public access,” Navalny assures.

Roads should be built not by Putin's former judo comrades, but by road builders who honestly won the competition. Today the metro is being built by another good friend of Putin, naturally, at an inflated price, because the mayor has no opportunity to honestly win the tender. Navalny proposes holding transparent competitions, giving the opportunity to work to truly the best specialists.

SYSTEMIC CHANGES

A young woman from the front row asks how Alexei, once he becomes mayor, will choose his team. “Moscow will be governed by tens of thousands of people, 85 percent of whom are not corrupt. And if we are talking about the top leadership, then what matters here are not surnames, but principles: if you stole, you will be punished,” Navalny replies. The current кадровый principle is best illustrated by the recent Oboronservis case, when the leadership is trying to evade responsibility.

HONEST MAYOR

“And what about Putin—how will you build relations with the authorities?” a woman’s voice rings out. “When I become mayor, I will act strictly according to the rules: if it says that an honest tender must be held for metro construction, then I will hold it. When Putin calls and asks to give all the contracts to Timchenko, I will not do that.” “Then the next day they’ll expose a bribe in your office!” an elderly man declares.

MOSCOVITES HAVE THE RIGHT TO KNOW

One of the participants in the meeting accuses Navalny: what right, she says, does he have to ask where Sobyanin got the money for numerous apartments for himself and his daughters. Navalny said that he has exactly that right. “I want the mayor of Moscow to be a person who is responsible for transparency and honesty in the distribution of budget funds,” Alexei noted. He explained that nationalization is absurd: companies, including state-owned ones, are not managed properly and by officials’ relatives. The issue should not be nationalization, but restoring order.

THERE IS MONEY

A young man in a gray T-shirt asks how the future mayor plans to increase social payments—you can’t just get money from nowhere. “To begin with, we will freeze the sums that have been stolen and redirect them into the city budget and into social payments,” the candidate replies. He also noted that the sources of additional payments are savings and the fight against corruption.

DADDY’S DAUGHTERS, OR ZHULPLAZA

Civil servant Sergei Sobyanin has been at the head of Moscow for nearly three years. During this time, many questions have accumulated for him, but he does not like to answer them. And he does not answer them. He remains silent about the sidewalk tiles that in many places became unusable soon after being laid. And yet this is hundreds of millions of rubles—either talentlessly wasted or simply stolen from the Moscow budget by unscrupulous officials. He is also silent about the landscaping of Tverskaya Street with shoddy shrubs costing eight million rubles each (experts estimate such “landscaping” to be at least ten times cheaper). And now Sobyanin has a new subject for silence: his daughters’ elite apartments.

MOSCOW

On the eve of the elections, the election commission published information on the income and property of Sergei Sobyanin, his wife, and his underage daughter for 2012. What immediately catches the eye is a 308-square-meter apartment in Moscow belonging to schoolgirl Olga Sergeyevna Sobyanina.

HOW MUCH DOES IT COST?

In open databases, it is easy to find the address of Olga Sobyanina's apartment: Moscow, Rochdelskaya Street, building 12, structure 1. This is a super-elite building in the center of Moscow next to the White House.

In the same building, an apartment with an area of 200.2 square meters is for sale. Its price is 103.8 million, or about 518 thousand rubles per square meter. It is not difficult to assume that the 308-square-meter apartment belonging to the minor daughter of a civil servant is worth approximately 173 million rubles.

HIS INCOME

Sergey Sobyanin first declared his income in 2000, when he was a candidate for governor of the Tyumen Region. His annual income in 1999 was 219 thousand rubles. In 2003, he published a declaration according to which he earned 1.6 million rubles in 2002. In subsequent years, incomes changed; official declarations show growth in the earnings and property of the family.

PRIVATIZED?

Sobyanin stated that the apartments in the center of Moscow had long been declared by them. “This is standard practice,” says the mayor's team. However, the public and the opposition question the legality and transparency of the origin of such expensive real estate among the family members of a high-ranking official.

THE CHILDREN OF A CIVIL SERVANT ARE EASY TO RECOGNIZE BY THEIR POSSESSION OF ELITE HOUSING AND UNQUESTIONABLE BUSINESS TALENTS

Human rights activists and journalists note that such cases are not isolated: officials' children gain access to elite housing and lucrative contracts, which raises legitimate questions about the origin of the funds and possible conflicts of interest. In a number of cases, the public demands inspections and the disclosure of full information about transactions and sources of income.

AN INDIGENT ORPHAN?

There remains a version that Sobyanin could have legally obtained housing under a social tenancy agreement. The law provides for such opportunities if the family's income level is below the subsistence minimum. However, in this case, the amounts and addresses raise doubts, and many demand a full-fledged investigation.

ST. PETERSBURG

The civil servant Sobyanin also has a second daughter, Anna, who is already an adult. In 2011, 25 weeks after her 25th birthday, Anna bought an apartment in St. Petersburg on Malaya Konyushennaya Street. This is the very center of the city, a prestigious and very expensive location. The area of Anna Sergeyevna's apartment is nearly 205 square meters, and the approximate price is about 116.6 million rubles. Where did the official's daughter get that kind of money? According to the official version, part of the funds came from the family's business.

HER BUSINESS

A year before buying the apartment, Anna became one of the founders of Forus-Group LLC. The company supplies luxury furniture to various sites, a list of which is available on the company's website. Its clients include government and commercial entities. This also raises questions about possible connections and advantages received by the company.

A TOUGH MANAGER

At the end of the year, Sobyanin is firmly in charge in Moscow: his official apartment and a number of other properties connected to the authorities raise questions. The opposition demands transparency and explanations regarding the acquisition of expensive real estate by members of the mayor's family.

ON SEPTEMBER 8, WE CHOOSE ALEXEI NAVALNY!

WHO IS NAVALNY?

ONE OF US

For many years, Alexei Navalny investigated cases of corruption in Moscow and across the country. For those who read news on the Internet, his name is synonymous with a successful fight against high-ranking officials and thieves. Together with his team, Alexei came up with and carried out public projects that improved the lives of ordinary people. City hall officials feed us promises, while Navalny's projects work.

“Real politics means saying what you really think, engaging in public and political activity, without asking anyone for permission”

Navalny is a public figure and anti-corruption activist who seeks transparency in the spending of budget funds, investigates corruption schemes, and initiates public investigations. He is convinced that only through public oversight and a change in the principles of governance is it possible to change the situation in the city and the country.

NAVALNY HAS ALREADY DONE A LOT

Navalny runs several successful projects to help citizens. He has united thousands of people in the fight against theft and inefficiency.

PEOPLE TRUST NAVALNY

People trust Navalny and voluntarily fund his projects. About 30 thousand people donate small sums of money to his Anti-Corruption Foundation, on which the foundation exists.

ROSZHKH

WE KNOW HOW TO MAKE THOSE WHO TAKE MONEY FROM US FOR HOUSING AND UTILITIES WORK

More than 90 thousand complaints about violations have been filed, more than 25 thousand violations have been remedied.

ROSYAMA

WE KNOW HOW TO MAKE BAD ROADS BETTER

More than 45 thousand complaints about potholes on the roads have been filed, more than 12 thousand potholes have been filled.

ROSPIL

WE KNOW HOW TO DEFEAT THEFT IN PUBLIC PROCUREMENT

The embezzlement of taxpayers' funds in the amount of 59 billion rubles has been prevented.

Alexei Navalny was born on June 4, 1976. He graduated from the law faculty of RSUH, then studied at the Financial Academy under the Government of the Russian Federation. He lives in Moscow. His wife is Yulia. Alexei has two children: a 12-year-old daughter and a 5-year-old son, Zakhar.

Contacts and social media: vk.com/teamnavalny facebook.com/teamnavalny instagram.com/teamnavalny odnoklassniki.ru/group/teamnavalny twitter.com/teamnavalny

Campaign headquarters: Ploshchad Lane 22 (495) 215-54-31 team@navalny.ru

Produced by LLC “Printing Complex”, 143300, Naro-Fominsk, Moscow Region, Kalinina St., 8/1. TIN 5030045907. Customer — candidate for the position of Mayor of Moscow Alexey Anatolyevich Navalny. The data are published in accordance with the requirements of the law.