At a meeting of supporters in Yekaterinburg, speakers said that candidate Lev Volkov, according to polling data received late, had been on track to win the election comfortably, but was removed by a ruling of the Supreme Court. They described this as a politically motivated deprivation of voters’ right to choose and as rendering donations and volunteer work meaningless. Despite this, participants called for the campaign against United Russia to continue, focusing on canvassing, election monitoring on December 4, 2011, and voter mobilization. In his speech, Alexei Navalny described the current authorities as corrupt, ineffective, and having lost their legitimacy, and called for their political defeat through lawful electoral means.
Text version
0:01

Hello, everyone.

0:08

We’re told that with the microphones

0:10

at some point everything might start working

0:12

properly, and we hope that until that moment

0:14

we’ll have enough air in our lungs. I can see

0:18

empty seats in the hall, and that

0:21

doesn’t really match the fact that people are standing

0:23

in the aisles. Those of you who have an empty

0:27

seat next to you, please raise your hands so that

0:29

the people in the aisles can see where

0:31

to go. Let’s take a minute for that.

0:36

Let’s allow for that. Announcements about today’s meeting were

0:39

made exclusively on my LiveJournal, so everyone

0:43

who came here reads it and, apparently,

0:47

supports me. So I want to say

0:49

a huge thank you for your support and

0:52

apologize that, so far, your support

0:57

hasn’t paid off.

0:59

Yesterday we

1:02

received delayed polling data from that

1:07

district, from the Oktyabrsky district. The polling

1:09

showed that we were winning this election

1:13

without question, you and I. But apparently

1:16

we weren’t the only ones who had that polling,

1:19

and that led to the results

1:22

you already know about. Nevertheless,

1:25

I apologize.

1:28

For some reason unknown to me,

1:31

we still should have won anyway.

1:33

It’s still a shame that it didn’t happen.

1:36

And huge thanks to everyone who helped

1:39

in this entire campaign. Your help was

1:41

enormous, invaluable. And by the decision of the

1:45

Supreme Court, which was handed down

1:49

the day before yesterday, they wiped out not only just over

1:53

1 million rubles in private

1:55

donations collected from all across the country

1:56

for my election campaign, but also, as I

1:59

calculated on the plane, roughly 20,000

2:02

person-hours of volunteer work in

2:05

my campaign headquarters, which went into

2:08

canvassing, helping with outreach, working with

2:11

people—all of that work. All that effort, all that

2:14

money was basically spat on.

2:17

Very blatantly. I can see a great many

2:18

people here who helped, and once again I ask

2:22

for your forgiveness. Now, look—on stage is

2:26

Alexei

2:28

Navalny. Originally,

2:30

it was planned that

2:32

—it’s clear what the purpose of this visit was.

2:35

Alexei was supposed to come in the final

2:36

week to, so to speak, once again

2:38

bring together all the helpers, all the

2:39

supporters, everyone who cares,

2:42

everyone sympathetic to our cause, and say: Guys,

2:44

come on, there’s one week left—everyone out into the streets,

2:47

to information pickets, hand out leaflets,

2:50

newspapers, help, help—there’s a chance,

2:52

a small one, but there is a chance to help get elected, because

2:55

this is very important, because the whole

2:57

country is watching.

2:58

Plus, of course, work at the polling stations, plus

3:01

of course campaign against the party of crooks and

3:05

thieves. Alexei came anyway, even though he already

3:09

knew that on December 4 I would not be taking part in the election,

3:12

and for that

3:13

many thanks to him.

3:15

He’ll say himself why he came. I want to

3:20

draw your attention to this: we

3:22

were running two campaigns in parallel. We had

3:26

a campaign in the Oktyabrsky district in

3:28

support of

3:30

candidate Volkov.

3:31

And

3:34

we invested enormous resources into it.

3:37

A huge number of newspapers were printed,

3:39

and a huge number of

3:40

events were held there—pickets, people standing in

3:42

courtyards, and all the rest. But that

3:46

campaign was not the only one.

3:49

In parallel, with the same headquarters and the same people,

3:51

in a sense almost underground, we were running

3:54

a campaign on the scale of the whole city,

3:56

maybe even the whole region: vote

3:59

for any party except the party of crooks and thieves.

4:02

That campaign may not have been as

4:05

visible or as successful, although 30,000

4:07

stickers were distributed, and you can

4:10

find them in the most unexpected places.

4:12

Dozens of people were also involved in it

4:15

as volunteers and participants.

4:18

So that campaign has not been canceled; it is

4:21

still going, and you can

4:22

take part in it—you can and should come,

4:25

sign up,

4:26

train in the election observer school, and monitor

4:29

the vote on December 4. We still

4:32

feel that the ice is cracking. Even though

4:35

winter is only just beginning, still,

4:37

it is cracking—that’s the feeling that hasn’t

4:39

left everyone who, all these days, in my

4:41

headquarters, worked in the streets, campaigned. There is

4:43

a sense that we can push and

4:45

break it.

4:47

Well, it seems not everyone has sat down yet,

4:50

although I can still see empty seats. But

4:52

all the same,

4:54

let’s give the floor to our guest. So, what’s going on

4:56

with the microphones? It turns out that for

4:58

me—well then—can those in the back rows

5:01

hear us at least a little? Yes? Excellent. Well then,

5:04

let’s go. Excellent. Thank you very much, dear

5:07

friends. It’s a great pleasure for me, for the second time,

5:09

to speak in Yekaterinburg. It’s very gratifying.

5:11

And, to be honest, it’s even a little unexpected

5:13

that so many people have gathered

5:16

to listen. Probably that’s less my

5:17

doing than the doing of your authorities, who

5:20

have gotten on your nerves so badly. Today I’ve already

5:23

had several meetings.

5:27

At each meeting, I begin by

5:31

retelling a rather

5:32

some wonderful news last night

5:34

I flew into Yekaterinburg, and I was met by

5:36

Volkov and Krasheninnikov. And so here I am,

5:39

walking straight through security, and there they are,

5:41

standing there with joyful smiles. I thought, well,

5:43

what are they so happy about? They’ve already been kicked out of the election.

5:46

Why are they celebrating? They say, “Listen, you know,”

5:49

in Uralmash (a district of Yekaterinburg), United Russia campaigners

5:51

are getting beaten up. That’s wonderful news.

5:54

Just now, I came back from

5:56

a meeting with volunteers, and they too

5:58

were saying, you know what the difference is between us and

6:00

United Russia campaigners?

6:02

Well, aside from the fact that we stand for

6:04

the right things, it’s that we can walk around

6:05

alone. They can’t. They get beaten, and they should be beaten.

6:10

Those people should be beaten, because I came here

6:13

basically because

6:15

a crime has been committed, because

6:17

they stole from me, from all of us,

6:22

at least a million rubles (about 1 million RUB) — including from me.

6:24

I campaigned so people would send money to Volkov.

6:26

Money.

6:27

They stole from him, they stole from you, they stole from all of us.

6:30

From these 20,000 people with signatures, from all of us,

6:34

they stole the chance to choose this

6:37

candidate. I don’t understand why some

6:39

random nobody, some jerk out of nowhere,

6:41

Mostovshchikov, should

6:43

get to decide whether we vote for Volkov or not.

6:46

He might have lost, maybe we would have voted for

6:48

someone else — but we want

6:51

him, if he raised the money and collected

6:53

the signatures and went into the election. A crime has been committed.

6:56

A crime.

6:58

And I think you all know who committed this

7:01

crime, who committed this crime,

7:03

who stole this from us.

7:07

It was the party of crooks and thieves. There is no such thing as United

7:10

Russia. Let’s all say it together:

7:13

the party of crooks and

7:15

thieves. I’m here too, and maybe

7:20

above all because

7:21

Yekaterinburg is the city where,

7:24

simply for historical reasons,

7:26

I feel that you can defeat the party

7:30

of crooks and thieves — not physically anymore,

7:32

like they do in Uralmash, but politically.

7:35

Here, in the last

7:38

election, they got 30% across the city of

7:40

Yekaterinburg. Right now, no polling,

7:42

not even the most favorable, gives them more than

7:45

20%. That’s why I came here to campaign

7:49

and I continue urging you to support

7:51

this election campaign. And now it has become

7:54

perhaps an even more important, more

7:55

serious part of this election

7:57

campaign. Forgive me, Alyona,

8:00

but maybe because you were removed from the ballot,

8:02

more people are feeling anger and even

8:05

hatred. I urge you to take this

8:07

very personally. When I

8:09

found out he had been removed — and I had spent

8:12

a huge amount of time urging everyone

8:14

to raise this money — inside me

8:16

there is sheer rage boiling. These people really did take away and

8:19

rob us, and I hope that now, in

8:22

this final week, we’ll manage to make

8:26

an extraordinary effort to crush these

8:28

crooks and thieves. Power in your

8:31

wonderful region belongs simply to

8:34

pathetic, incompetent, and

8:37

monstrously cowardly people. That video —

8:40

everyone saw the video where they simply

8:42

cut him off the air after the words

8:44

“governor of Sverdlovsk Oblast” — it’s just

8:48

a disgrace. There they sit, those people, and

8:51

on one side they’re protected by

8:53

the police, on the other side by the FSB (Russia’s security service),

8:56

over there stands the sanitary inspectorate, here stands

8:58

the fire inspectorate. They have an enormous

9:00

amount of money. Everyone works for them.

9:02

State employees work for them. The corrupt

9:05

media works for them. Everything is for them, and still, on some

9:08

pathetic TV channel watched by three

9:10

and a half people, they cut him off

9:13

right at the words

9:14

“governor of Sverdlovsk Oblast.” And for that, we

9:17

have to hit back. I call on everyone, in

9:21

this final week — it is the decisive week — and

9:23

you have every opportunity to do it,

9:26

because this machine of election fraud,

9:28

fortunately,

9:30

in the region, in the city of Yekaterinburg,

9:31

works much worse than

9:35

it does in Chechnya, Tambov, or even Moscow,

9:37

for historical reasons.

9:39

And now everyone has the opportunity

9:45

to print out a leaflet from our website against

9:48

United Russia, against the party of crooks and thieves,

9:51

stick it up in your apartment building entrance, tell

9:53

five people you know, urge them to go vote,

9:55

become election observers, and smash, tear apart

9:58

these people on the fourth, show

10:00

everyone that it will begin in the city of Yekaterinburg.

10:04

If you want to call it a revolution,

10:07

then this filthy government is no longer needed by anyone.

10:10

The thing is, yes, Putin and

10:13

United Russia do have some votes,

10:16

some percentages, some support.

10:18

But let them get only as much as they are

10:21

entitled to by law and by

10:23

justice. Let them get 20%.

10:25

Let them get 25%, but they have no right

10:29

to take all power away from us. These people have seized

10:32

all power in the country, they have monopolized

10:36

these resources — and what have they given us in return?

10:40

That is, to monopolize everything.

10:43

To concentrate everything in their hands—they showed us that.

10:46

to us.

10:48

Badminton, you see—we wanted something from them after 12

10:51

years of Putin in power, 12 years of a colossal

10:55

flow of money. In its entire history, Russia

10:59

—the Russian Empire, the Soviet Union—never

11:01

received even

11:03

a third of this money. An enormous amount

11:06

of petrodollars, with prices for all raw materials

11:08

going through the roof. What did we want to get for that

11:10

money? Police reform, for one. We wanted

11:15

army reform. We wanted some kind of

11:18

housing and utilities reform—something, anything. Buy us, with

11:20

that money, at least some kind of

11:22

reform. We wanted at least some kind of

11:24

order restored. We wanted the elimination

11:27

of the chaos. They did do a few things, of course—no one

11:30

can say nothing was done after 2003.

11:34

There was, for example, tax

11:41

reform. Let's put it this way: we shouldn't

11:44

criticize them where criticism isn't deserved.

11:47

There were achievements; it would be foolish

11:50

to deny that Putin had a period when

11:53

his rating was 70 percent. There still is

11:56

some support. But from 2004

11:59

to 2011, what did these people do? They stole. They

12:04

did absolutely nothing. What is the most

12:07

popular flight out of Moscow to

12:10

some city—which one? First, St. Petersburg; second,

12:13

London. Do you understand? And those bastards still

12:17

have the nerve to say that

12:19

people like Volkov and Navalny

12:21

are acting on orders from some

12:23

American oligarchs who want

12:26

to destroy the country. I live in a district of Moscow, and I

12:30

don't know how it compares with Yekaterinburg,

12:32

but right next to my home

12:33

there's an oil refinery, and my children

12:36

go to the local—so that's the whole

12:40

secret, that's exactly the secret. I

12:43

look around: I live in Moscow, I have an oil

12:45

refinery nearby, oil prices are

12:48

sky-high, my children go to the local

12:50

kindergarten and the local school, and I

12:52

get absolutely nothing from it. And I

12:54

see planes constantly flying from Moscow to

12:57

London, ferrying these officials around everywhere. Their children

13:00

live abroad, they all have bank accounts there,

13:02

they all own property there. And what do we get? What do

13:05

we get? Only the smoke from that

13:06

oil refinery, because

13:08

the money flows straight to London.

13:10

The same thing is happening, the same thing

13:12

is happening everywhere. These people gave us

13:14

nothing, and they cannot do anything. I

13:16

have given this example many times already—the

13:18

Magnitsky case. Everyone in this hall knows it.

13:22

There were 10 police officers, three prosecutors, five

13:26

FSB officers—outright gangsters. It's all

13:29

clear, everyone knows where their money is, how

13:32

they looted, and so on. Everyone knows.

13:34

Everything has been exposed. Well then, put those 10 people

13:37

in prison. They can't do it,

13:40

because those 10 people tortured

13:42

and killed Magnitsky, but at some point

13:45

they were also doing something useful for them.

13:47

The system created by Putin—United

13:50

Russia—has become useless. And the most

13:52

important thing is why it will collapse: not because

13:55

we here will stage some kind of artificial

13:56

revolution, but because it is useless.

13:59

It gives us nothing. Do we really believe that

14:03

these two badminton players

14:06

will somehow be able to do something in

14:09

the future, that they will once again somehow

14:11

deliver some reform for us? Does even one person believe

14:13

that?

14:15

No. They can't do it, and they don't

14:18

know how to do it, and they don't

14:20

want to. These people are traitors to the national

14:24

interest, and that's not a figure of speech—they really are

14:27

absolute traitors. Look

14:29

at one of the favorite subjects of my

14:31

investigations: Timchenko, Putin's crony,

14:34

who became a billionaire and is on the

14:36

Forbes list. He gave up his Russian

14:38

citizenship and is now a citizen

14:40

of Finland, lives in Switzerland, sits there

14:43

with a cigar, and the oil money keeps flowing to him.

14:45

How much does he have now—about 6, I think,

14:47

billion

14:48

dollars. They betrayed the country, all those

14:52

Rotenbergs and all the rest. Here's my

14:54

favorite example. I don't know, maybe I gave it at

14:56

the last meeting too, but

14:59

this stream here—

15:02

this gas pipeline they built in

15:04

Germany, which Putin opened with great pomp

15:06

and so on. A kilometer of that

15:09

pipeline in Germany costs €2 million, while in

15:12

Russia, in the Leningrad Region, it costs

15:15

€6 million per kilometer—three times as much.

15:17

Why? Because the contractors are the

15:19

Rotenberg brothers, Putin's associates, one of whom is

15:22

Putin's judo partner. How can I, how can we,

15:25

look at that? If you look at

15:27

Gazprom's contractors and suppliers, we

15:29

will see that large-diameter pipe there is supplied

15:32

by the wife of one of the members

15:34

of the management board, a former music

15:37

teacher, and so on and so forth.

15:39

Schemes are openly published showing

15:42

that what is being built in Russia now is

15:44

a new feudalism. There is simply no other way

15:48

to describe it.

15:51

It's like that famous joke that used to go around.

15:53

A few years ago, when there was

15:54

this kind of presidium on stage, some party officials there,

15:58

United

15:59

on stage, they said to me: well, we've already

16:01

sort of taken care of ourselves, bought this

16:04

bought that, now it's time to think about the people. And

16:06

someone from the audience says: yeah, 200 serfs per soul

16:09

wouldn't hurt. And that's already been put into practice.

16:13

A real feudal system in which

16:15

crooks have seized power, and their children

16:18

just look at the board of directors of any

16:20

bank — sitting there are the children of these FSB officers (Russia's security service),

16:24

Patrushev's children, and whoever our current, current

16:28

FSB director is.

16:30

In theory, they are supposed to be the ones

16:33

fighting the people who are

16:35

robbing us, but they are taking part in that robbery.

16:37

They've put their own children in place so that the children

16:39

can rob us. They protected, and they still protect, their

16:43

children, people like

16:44

us. That's why we do not need this government, and

16:49

it must be changed. I very much wanted

16:52

for this to begin with the city of

16:54

Yekaterinburg. That does not mean we should stage

16:57

a revolution or set fire to some government building.

17:00

We need to do everything possible so that

17:02

they get exactly what they

17:04

deserve — their

17:07

20%. In the next elections, we must

17:10

keep pressing these people until they lose

17:12

their monopoly on power, until they give us

17:14

the opportunity — you, me, him —

17:16

the opportunity to take part in elections in which

17:17

we may very well

17:19

lose. Very likely. It's entirely possible that

17:22

if we make something happen now, there will be

17:24

free elections and we will lose, and no one

17:26

present here will become

17:27

president, or even a boss.

17:30

So what? At least the government will be honest.

17:33

The government will be legitimate, at least.

17:34

There will be some kind of change. Because

17:36

what we are seeing now is just one step short of

17:39

actually formalizing those

17:40

really entrenching some kind of

17:42

200 serfs for every family — that's exactly how all of this is being built.

17:46

That is precisely how it works. Look at what is happening in

17:47

Moscow — there are more Mercedes cars there than in all of

17:50

Germany, it seems to me.

17:52

You know about Moscow already. For how many

17:56

million rubles did your governor buy

17:59

his car? For 8 million rubles (about US$85,000-90,000). There is not a single

18:03

large country in the world where some

18:06

regional governor drives a car that

18:08

expensive. Even your mayor

18:10

of Yekaterinburg bought one

18:14

for 6.4 million rubles (about US$68,000-72,000). We even had a case where the head of

18:17

the Central Base Customs office bought one for 9

18:19

million rubles (about US$95,000-100,000). What is he planning to haul around in it?

18:22

Why can't you just buy yourself a very

18:23

expensive car for, say, 1 million rubles (about US$10,000-11,000)?

18:25

No, he needs something special. That is, he wants

18:27

to drive on his own road, and for mud to fly at us

18:30

not from ordinary tires, but from

18:32

some kind of golden ones. That's what they

18:35

want. So now I am wrapping up my

18:38

remarks so that we have more time

18:40

left for questions. I want to say this:

18:43

these people are afraid. That fear is simply

18:48

spreading across the whole country; you can feel the fear,

18:50

the fear of your vile, cowardly

18:52

governor and his whole gang — you can physically

18:55

feel it. Otherwise they would not have

18:57

shut things down.

19:00

They would not have cut this off in the middle, and they would not have

19:02

taken down those 'won in principle' posters — what happened?

19:05

But they are afraid. That is, they are

19:08

afraid. And we need to understand that in order

19:11

to throw them out, to remove them, we do not

19:13

need some huge crowds, I don't know,

19:16

hundreds of thousands of people. What we need is an effective

19:20

position and energetic work. A fairly

19:23

small number of people is enough.

19:28

We just need to do everything possible over the

19:30

final week, to work hard,

19:32

to help the observers a little, and we understand:

19:35

if we can bring United Russia's rating down by another 5%, that needs to

19:38

be done. St. Petersburg, in the famous phrase, was the cradle

19:41

of three revolutions. Let's

19:43

make sure Yekaterinburg becomes the cradle of at least

19:46

one. Thank you.

Original