Text version
0:00

[music]

0:44

Good evening, everyone. In Moscow it's 8:06 p.m. Don't

0:48

worry, we're not being searched, I haven't been

0:50

arrested — it's a technical delay

0:51

connected with the fact that after the searches

0:54

everything here is being held together a little bit

0:55

by sheer goodwill, and something broke off, so it was being fixed. Still,

0:58

I'm still here in the studio — Alexei

1:01

Navalny, or a U.S. Marine, as one

1:06

Kremlin military expert called me. If you

1:09

look at

1:10

various Kremlin TV shows, you'll see

1:12

a military expert there, and that expert

1:14

stated that while I was at

1:15

Yale University, me — that is, not

1:18

the real Navalny — was kidnapped,

1:20

and replaced with a U.S. Marine. So

1:23

the person sitting before you now is a U.S. Marine. Today we

1:27

will be raising money for

1:28

restoring the structure of our

1:31

regional headquarters. Apparently we'll be raising it

1:32

for quite a while, because

1:34

today we've had more than 200 searches in 41

1:38

cities across Russia. I'll talk about that later, but

1:41

first, of course, I want to start with

1:43

what caused these searches, because of which

1:47

there's a link below this video

1:50

for donations, so I'm asking you very strongly

1:52

to take a look there. In fact, the reason

1:55

was, naturally, our victory. Congratulations

1:57

my friends — it's genuinely so nice to say that.

1:59

It was so nice to read those great

2:00

comments and messages saying, you know,

2:03

"For the first time in my life, I voted for

2:05

the candidate I was told to support, and he won." It's so nice.

2:08

In all my recent broadcasts, and in the last

2:12

broadcast, I started with rather strange phrases

2:14

like,

2:14

"Guys, we need to believe in our own strength." It

2:17

all sounded strange. I admit

2:20

it sounded strange, and even to me

2:22

— I mean, it had to be said, because that

2:24

was the main thing, but it was pretty hard

2:29

to come out with some kind of pompous

2:31

phrase, because what does "believe in yourself" even

2:32

mean, really? But it turned out that this

2:35

was the key thing. We believed

2:40

in ourselves, and we gave United Russia a pretty serious

2:43

beating. We just didn't believe in ourselves quite well enough,

2:45

because it turned out

2:47

already now — as became clear by Tuesday —

2:50

that we actually could have taken from them

2:53

even more, at least in Moscow. Back on

2:57

Saturday, and even on Sunday afternoon,

2:59

it seemed unlikely, but it turned out that we

3:01

were this close

3:04

to simply taking everything from them. In that

3:06

sense, Smart Voting did not

3:10

crush United Russia across the whole country,

3:13

no, certainly not, and we didn't — we didn't

3:15

take everything. Though we did take from United Russia

3:18

its majority in Moscow.

3:20

But still, if a few mandates hadn't been stolen,

3:22

Smart Voting and various

3:24

additional circumstances in

3:25

Khabarovsk completely destroyed

3:28

United Russia in Khabarovsk and the Khabarovsk region. Smart

3:29

Voting — but overall, the main thing happened:

3:32

we elected deputies. Together, we decided

3:36

which people we would support,

3:39

then we came and voted

3:42

and made them deputies in Moscow, in

3:46

St. Petersburg, and in other places.

3:48

This had happened before, but previously it

3:50

was the exception.

3:52

It was assumed that only through party

3:56

lists

3:56

could opposition candidates be guaranteed

3:58

to get in — everyone understood they'd get

4:01

15 percent or so, and that you had to

4:04

squeeze onto that list in order

4:07

to become a guaranteed deputy. But

4:08

running in a single-member district — that was a dead

4:11

end, because wherever there were just names on the ballot,

4:13

United Russia always won. And

4:16

we changed that. Yes, for now we've changed it in

4:19

Moscow, because for now in Moscow

4:21

there were enough people

4:23

who believed in themselves. But we'll do it

4:25

across the whole country. So right now I want

4:28

to give you just a few figures and examples

4:30

showing how great it is that

4:35

Smart Voting worked. But our task

4:36

organizationally right now is simply

4:38

to tell everyone about it, because right now

4:40

several hundred

4:42

thousand people took part in it. If in the next cycle

4:45

it's a couple of million, and in the cycle after that 10

4:47

million, then that's it — goodbye, United

4:50

Russia. We will win in every

4:51

election. We won't turn into garbage, and we won't

4:53

of course turn into United Russia ourselves,

4:55

but in any case, we will turn all of

4:58

this into a basic

5:00

confrontation with United Russia, the party

5:02

of power.

5:03

Smart Voting — and that's great, because

5:05

because

5:06

in fact, no party is going to

5:08

object to this, because we

5:10

helped everyone: the Communists formed a large caucus,

5:13

bigger than they've had in Moscow for a long time;

5:15

A Just Russia formed a caucus;

5:17

Yabloko formed a caucus. Everyone is pleased, everyone is

5:19

happy, everyone got a success they hadn't had

5:22

for many, many years. So, the overall

5:25

framework: let's remember what elections

5:26

actually are. Right now, in 25, in my view,

5:33

regions of the country

5:33

election campaigns were underway; in total there were 31

5:37

campaigns covered by

5:39

Smart Voting. Elections are always structured

5:42

like this: there is a party list,

5:44

where you vote for a party, and there are

5:46

single-member district candidates, where you vote

5:49

by name. In Moscow there was no party-list

5:51

component — here people voted only for names,

5:52

because United Russia was confident

5:55

that in this way they would take one hundred

5:57

percent of the seats, because wherever people vote for

5:59

a specific name, the opposition had never won

6:01

before, xxx

6:02

let's start first with the party

6:05

lists. This is very important, because the leader

6:09

of the new United Russia is, well,

6:10

nationwide—in general, the formal leader

6:13

of United Russia nationwide is

6:14

Dmitry Medvedev, Vladimir Putin, and, and

6:17

is the spiritual leader, but the main

6:20

figure speaking here is Mr. Turchak. He

6:23

heads it—let's take a look at what

6:24

he said. He said verbatim: United

6:27

Russia crushed everyone in these elections.

6:31

Can we show the graphic? I hope that

6:34

they're showing you this graphic—I can't see it.

6:36

United Russia crushed everyone in these

6:38

elections. So let's see exactly how

6:41

they supposedly crushed them—let's see in what way.

6:48

United Russia's representation

6:50

changed on the party lists. You

6:52

can see that it shrank absolutely

6:55

everywhere. Nadia, I'm very—I apologize for

6:59

the technical problems. I really hope that

7:01

they're showing you this graphic. Guys, come

7:04

over to me—sorry.

7:05

And tell me, are we showing the graphics or

7:07

not? It would be strange otherwise. We are showing them?

7:09

Finally, thank you very much, hooray. And once again,

7:12

sorry—when you send us a bunch of

7:15

money, everything will work perfectly for us

7:16

because we'll get properly

7:17

equipped. You're looking at the party

7:19

lists.

7:20

of United Russia. You can see that almost everywhere

7:22

they took a hit; in some places

7:25

Khabarovsk Krai

7:27

as I already said, they were completely

7:28

wiped out. Very interesting—look below.

7:30

Do you see the city of Sevastopol?

7:32

There of all places, it would seem that everyone

7:36

prays to Putin's portrait, and there the effect

7:39

of the 'Crimean Spring' (the 2014 annexation of Crimea) and everything else

7:40

should be at its maximum.

7:41

works in the city—but in Sevastopol, not at all,

7:44

excuse my language: United Russia lost 38 percent

7:46

there. So you see,

7:48

just about everywhere, except in

7:49

the Kabardino-Balkarian Republic,

7:51

the elections were absolutely, totally

7:53

falsified. Everywhere they lost

7:56

well, in some places a lot, in others a little, and that

7:58

is already great. Most importantly, we can see a trend

8:00

across the whole country. I'm sure that of course this

8:04

trend is also connected with our campaign

8:07

that we ran against United Russia,

8:08

the Smart Voting campaign. People were going out

8:10

and looking for ways to vote

8:14

against United Russia, which is why it fell. As for

8:16

this talk of 'crushing'—United Russia definitely didn't

8:19

crush anyone on the party lists; on the contrary,

8:22

everyone

8:23

—I apologize for the wording, that's Turchak's expression—

8:25

everyone crushed United Russia. Now let's

8:28

look at those single-member

8:30

districts, where there was an individual name on the ballot.

8:32

United Russia always thought that everything

8:34

was great there. You know that now they

8:36

even want to make State Duma elections so that all

8:39

450 seats are elected only in single-member districts, that is,

8:42

people would vote only for a name, because

8:44

that was where they were kings. In total, there were

8:46

up for grabs

8:47

in this kind of election in the previous

8:50

electoral cycle—in 2014,

8:53

there were 762 seats contested, and of those 762

8:58

United Russia then, as you

9:00

can see, won 643.

9:04

So, in other words, it had complete dominance.

9:05

Now, as a result of Smart Voting

9:09

and other factors—but nevertheless Smart

9:11

Voting was obviously the key

9:14

factor—in all of this, United Russia

9:17

seriously lost its

9:19

representation. It dropped—well, this is

9:23

of course not in a dramatic way, but as

9:25

you can see, quite significantly. They

9:29

lost ground in the number of single-member

9:31

candidates.

9:31

Of them, 145 people across the country were

9:34

backed by us through Smart Voting. That is,

9:37

we can see that it worked, one way or another,

9:39

across the whole country, although, to be honest, yes,

9:42

it's clear that first and foremost you

9:45

made Smart Voting happen through your efforts,

9:47

through those who watch this program or

9:49

through those who watch the videos. But broadly speaking,

9:51

essentially, your own

9:53

Smart Voting—you and those whom you

9:56

persuaded—mostly live in

9:58

large cities, and it's fairly hard for us

10:01

to reach smaller towns and

10:04

more remote areas, but even there

10:06

it worked—worked absolutely brilliantly.

10:09

But let's look at Khabarovsk again.

10:11

Yes, Khabarovsk is a special case. There,

10:15

basically, the governor represents

10:17

not United Russia but the LDPR (Liberal Democratic Party of Russia), and there

10:19

United Russia was absolutely trampled.

10:22

Because there, essentially, the

10:26

administrative resource was removed: the LDPR governor

10:29

simply chose not to help

10:33

United Russia. Look at what happened

10:35

to United Russia: in the Khabarovsk City

10:37

Duma and the Khabarovsk

10:39

Legislative Assembly, they have nothing at all.

10:40

In the legislative assembly they controlled one hundred

10:43

percent; now they control zero

10:45

percent. And you can see that most of the

10:48

candidates were Smart Voting picks. Zhirik (Vladimir Zhirinovsky's nickname)

10:50

was ranting about this very amusingly. Let's

10:53

watch Vladimir Zhirinovsky

10:54

shout that Smart Voting has absolutely

10:57

nothing whatsoever to do with

10:58

Khabarovsk. 'Navalny's got some nerve,' he says,

11:01

'claiming he did this for us. Have you completely lost

11:02

your mind? You need a psychiatrist...'

11:06

We’re winning there, and somehow he tried to latch onto it.

11:08

He also said something there about helping the LDPR in Moscow.

11:11

He doesn’t understand that—I heard it myself.

11:14

with my own ears... give him a piece of my mind.

11:16

under no circumstances for United Russia, but for

11:19

the Communists in that round—it's astonishing.

11:21

because of Yabloko and the LDPR, and you’re a scoundrel.

11:24

normal [__] you’re morally

11:28

[__] you, Navalny—well, actually I

11:31

really am not going to

11:33

credit Smart Voting with everything that

11:36

belongs to the vote, of course.

11:37

The main factor in Khabarovsk Krai was

11:39

that there was no administrative machine behind

11:42

United Russia, but nevertheless Smart

11:45

Voting kind of finished it off for good.

11:47

That was the final blow, and in that sense

11:49

Zhirinovsky was completely wrong when

11:51

he says that I was supposedly calling in

11:52

Moscow not to support the LDPR—that’s just nonsense.

11:56

In Moscow, Smart Voting basically could not

11:59

support the LDPR, because

12:01

there simply are no strong LDPR candidates here, and

12:04

in Moscow people don’t vote for them; they

12:06

vote for them in the Far East.

12:08

That’s where they have an advantage, and so in the Far

12:10

East we supported Furgal’s candidates

12:11

and

12:13

LDPR candidates; in that sense they are against

12:16

United Russia, and we are breaking United Russia’s monopoly.

12:19

We made our contribution, and you have

12:23

a very active штаб (campaign office) in Khabarovsk.

12:25

There’s a great story involving the singer Vika

12:28

Tsyganova—you know her? For the youngest

12:31

members of our audience,

12:33

17 seconds—let’s take a look.

12:44

This is what I’m talking about... 7.

12:50

[music]

12:54

In short, Vika Tsyganova really is

12:56

a fairly popular singer, at least

12:59

among the older generation—one hundred

13:00

percent of them know her. Tsyganova has that kind of

13:02

patriotic image,

13:04

with songs like “Russian Vodka,” “St. Andrew’s

13:06

Banner”—she’s well known, and

13:08

United Russia’s idea was very simple.

13:10

They thought: well, the LDPR people are sitting there everywhere,

13:12

but now we’ll just go ahead and

13:15

wipe out the entire opposition—both the Communists and the LDPR—

13:18

because we’ll simply nominate a famous

13:20

person, Vika Tsyganova, and pensioners will come out for her,

13:22

they’ll say, “Oh yes, that’s Vika,” and

13:24

they’ll vote for her. And Vika Tsyganova

13:26

came in third because she ran from

13:29

United Russia. But that’s not even the best part.

13:31

The best part is not that.

13:34

The best part is that Vika Tsyganova

13:36

said after the election—and after the election

13:39

she gave an interview and said, “I lost

13:42

because of that lousy United Russia.”

13:44

Let’s take a look: “United Russia

13:46

disgraced me and sank me, so I am not

13:50

going to lobby for the interests of those who

13:51

disgraced me—the people who ran my

13:53

election campaign.” In other words, a person

13:57

ran from United Russia and lost

14:00

because she was with United Russia. Out of affection for Tsyganova, had she run from another party,

14:02

from another party, then with a high

14:04

probability she would have won. And just

14:07

a moment earlier she was standing there with all those

14:09

slogans and banners, and it said

14:11

“Vika Tsyganova of United Russia,” and the

14:13

next day she comes out and says, “They

14:15

disgraced me, they sank me.”

14:17

A similarly great story happened in

14:19

Moscow too, and I’ll talk about that a bit later, but it’s

14:22

great—people recoil from all of this.

14:25

United Russia should become like a plague party,

14:28

one everyone runs away from, and we

14:32

—the people who make Smart Voting happen—

14:34

must make the single biggest

14:37

contribution to that.

14:37

Irkutsk—I’m talking about the whole

14:40

country right now, but let’s look at Irkutsk.

14:42

United Russia was absolutely crushed there.

14:47

Look: in 2014 they controlled

14:49

fully two-thirds and did whatever they wanted in

14:52

the city duma (city council); now they are the opposition.

14:56

And nine out of 21 opposition candidates

14:59

got through thanks to Smart Voting, so here too

15:00

we can see

15:02

the success of our whole undertaking in Siberia.

15:07

Moscow.

15:09

That, of course, was the most dramatic of all, and we sat

15:17

here through the night until 5 a.m., until 6 a.m.,

15:19

sitting in the штаб (campaign office), and actually everyone felt

15:21

very, very sad, even though it would seem

15:24

we should have been very, very happy, well

15:27

yes, because even when they stole

15:28

seats, 20, 24, or 25 people out of

15:33

45 got through thanks to Smart Voting,

15:35

thanks to their own work and to Smart

15:37

Voting. Of course, Smart Voting is not

15:38

some magic button where we can turn just anyone

15:40

into a deputy [__]; the candidate has to

15:42

do the work, and we simply

15:44

help, and then he becomes a deputy.

15:47

That’s more or less how it works. But they

15:49

were taking away seats.

15:50

And honestly, the mood here was just depressing,

15:52

and it was depressing for one reason: we

15:54

sat there saying to ourselves, “My God, damn,

15:57

if only we had understood that we just needed to bring

16:00

a few more people out, we would have killed ourselves doing it,”

16:05

because the main number regarding

16:08

the Moscow elections is this:

16:11

in Moscow,

16:12

the people who came—the people who came to

16:14

the polls—mostly, the majority of those

16:17

who showed up voted for Smart Voting

16:19

candidates. You can look at this

16:22

figure on this slide, and if not, you can

16:25

check my blog: 580,000

16:28

people came to vote for Smart Voting

16:30

candidates, and 550,000 for United

16:33

Russia. So basically,

16:34

the majority of Muscovites who came out

16:37

voted for the opposition. If we had...

16:40

That was our turnout, right there.

16:43

And because of that, I just sat there thinking: we didn't quite push it far enough.

16:46

I was genuinely devastated on

16:48

the victory night — we only needed

16:51

50,000 more people.

16:52

We just needed to add them to the number we already had,

16:55

just 10 percent more — 50,000

16:57

people is nothing at all for Moscow.

16:58

United Russia would have gotten nothing, and I

17:01

just sat there, and that thought

17:03

was killing me: that we just

17:06

fell a tiny bit short. We have a huge number

17:08

of candidates

17:09

who lost in places where there was

17:11

fraud, where there was

17:14

and United Russia simply stole the victory,

17:16

padding its total by 100, 200, or 300 votes.

17:18

There really are districts where, for an

17:21

opposition candidate, without any fraud,

17:22

backed by Smart Voting,

17:24

500 votes, 700 votes, 1,000

17:26

votes would have been enough.

17:27

Such a ridiculous number. We really could have

17:31

absolutely crushed them. I don't know what they

17:34

would have done — I mean, they would have

17:35

canceled the election, one hundred percent, or

17:37

declared some kind of martial law or whatever

17:39

else — I don't know. But it was so

17:42

close, and we could hardly believe it ourselves.

17:45

We ran a kind of office pool here at the Anti-Corruption Foundation

17:49

about how many, how many

17:52

Smart Voting candidates would get through in

17:53

Moscow. I said the number would be 15; I talked about it in

17:56

a video. Mostly people were like,

17:59

when I said 15, they were like, sure,

18:01

you're just trying to cheer yourself up. They were saying 8, 7, 2,

18:04

people — Bogomolov from the video

18:07

production team and Sobol said 20 or 22, and I

18:10

thought: these people don't understand anything,

18:12

they're just talking nonsense. I mean, they seem like

18:14

grown adults involved in politics,

18:17

especially Sobol saying 22 — well,

18:19

completely crazy. But that was exactly the kind of swing we needed,

18:22

we needed to go in with exactly that kind of momentum,

18:25

because in reality, we won more

18:28

than anyone predicted, more than even we

18:31

predicted.

18:32

Still, in the end,

18:34

it turned out great. Look: we got

18:38

20 people elected; 6 more mandates were stolen, making 26.

18:42

The Communists now have a huge

18:44

faction of 13 people, and I was already waiting

18:50

for all sorts of people to start

18:53

showing off and shouting, "Alexei,

18:56

look what happened — the Communists got in, and they

18:57

must be silent about Stalin," that the Communists

19:00

moved faster than A Just Russia, faster

19:02

than Yabloko (a liberal Russian political party).

19:03

They've already put forward a resolution. Let's look at

19:06

this resolution — what does it say, what

19:07

have the Communist deputies written? We can see

19:11

this resolution — they'll show it to us now.

19:13

And it says that they demand — here,

19:17

please — a statement by the newly elected

19:19

deputies of the Moscow City Duma

19:20

demanding an end to criminal cases. They write

19:25

right here, using the words "political prisoners."

19:27

They demand the right to assembly, they demand

19:30

and declare that they will demand

19:31

release, that they will fight. They declare that

19:34

electronic voting must be abolished.

19:35

They declare that it is necessary

19:38

to investigate corruption cases that

19:40

received broad publicity during

19:42

the election campaign. And obviously,

19:43

they mean the investigations that

19:45

we carried out. So you and I not only

19:48

elected these deputies ourselves, but at least

19:50

for now — and of course deputies do have a tendency

19:53

to go bad; they can be bought,

19:55

they can be manipulated, they can be deceived, and

19:57

so on — but at least for now we

20:00

see that the people who stood there

20:03

and said those things in the square have now made it

20:06

into the Duma and are saying exactly the same things. That's

20:09

really cool, and I just want to

20:11

congratulate everyone very warmly. The video I want

20:15

to show about Metelsky and Shuvalova — I've shown it

20:21

several times — has this moment in it:

20:23

a deputy from the very center of Moscow,

20:25

Yelena Shuvalova — she really fought, and on

20:28

election night they wanted to steal that

20:30

victory from her. You could clearly see that the protocol

20:33

from one of the commissions was missing; they wanted

20:35

to throw her out because she was so sharply

20:36

oppositional, so firmly and sharply

20:37

opposition-minded. And after the election, when it was already clear

20:39

to the city authorities

20:42

what was happening, she posted a short video

20:45

of a verbal clash with deputy Metelsky,

20:48

who was probably the main trophy for the Anti-Corruption Foundation

20:50

in this whole story. It's simply

20:53

the best demonstration of what

20:57

happened. Listen to how Metelsky

21:00

talks to her in the Moscow City Duma chamber,

21:03

how confident he is in his victory — and

21:07

two days later he was no longer untouchable.

21:10

Let's listen.

21:11

Today they plan to consider

21:15

legislative proposals that are disastrous for the city and for the country as a whole.

21:19

Draft laws.

21:23

I ask

21:24

everyone sitting in this hall to think

21:28

about the degree of responsibility they are

21:32

taking on today. People trust us.

21:36

And Muscovites, unlike you — and we are not

21:39

calling for any upheaval in the country,

21:42

coups, or all the rest of that

21:44

nonsense that is now being told to us in the name

21:46

of all Muscovites.

21:48

So I strongly recommend always thinking about

21:51

what you are saying. And Muscovites,

21:54

believe me, will sort it out — and we won't have

21:57

to wait long. We won't have to wait long.

22:00

You see, that's the whole meaning of what

22:04

happened: these brazen faces sat there

22:07

saying, "Unlike you, we are not calling for this, we

22:10

know better what Muscovites want, and they..."

22:13

They’re lying — Metelsky had been sitting there for, what, 15 years or so,

22:15

I don’t remember exactly anymore, and there he was, sitting there,

22:18

completely convinced that no one would ever force him out of there,

22:22

that he had become glued to that place.

22:25

Because he’s a billionaire, a hotel owner,

22:27

a United Russia party member — he paid these people off, paid those people off,

22:30

everyone around him was bought, and so, well,

22:34

Muscovites came and said — by the way,

22:35

additionally, it seems to me this was to a large extent

22:37

the Metelsky effect: what actually happened was

22:40

a total purge carried out by

22:41

United Russia in eastern Moscow. Usually,

22:44

the opposition vote comes from the center and

22:46

the southwest, but here, look — it was precisely in

22:50

eastern Moscow.

22:51

They simply wiped them out everywhere there, and it seems to me

22:54

this was also part of the effect of

22:56

Metelsky, who was heavily involved in all sorts of things there

22:58

in eastern Moscow, and simply

23:01

the sheer brazenness, arrogance, and audacity of these

23:04

people reached such proportions

23:06

that when we gave people this

23:09

small tool for consolidation — Smart Voting —

23:11

goodbye, United Russia. Smart Voting

23:15

worked.

23:16

Well, they had their own rigged kind of voting,

23:17

and United Russia set up

23:22

electronic voting in three districts, and

23:24

of course we understood that most likely this

23:28

would be some kind of mechanism for falsification,

23:30

but this whole thing was actively pushed by

23:32

Alexei Alexeyevich Venediktov, editor-in-chief

23:34

of Echo of Moscow (a Russian radio station).

23:35

And it was supposedly hard to

23:37

suspect him of directly

23:39

working for some kind of

23:40

fraud machine. Well, you could assume

23:43

that he was, say, helping Moscow City Hall

23:45

put together some kind of, well, something or other,

23:47

some shady scheme — but it turned out that this electronic

23:50

voting, this broken

23:52

thing, crashed several times during the day,

23:53

and then it turned out that, well,

23:56

everything there was simply faked. Let’s look

23:59

at the table for this electronic voting;

24:02

just by looking at it

24:03

you can see that the results at these

24:08

polling stations, where people voted

24:10

electronically, are just completely

24:12

different from

24:15

— you see, compare ordinary

24:17

voting, where people brought in paper ballots,

24:19

and compare it with electronic voting, and

24:22

you immediately see how different the bars are.

24:24

Rusetskaya, Tsvetkov, and Kartavtseva — these are three

24:25

United Russia candidates. You see how much fewer votes

24:28

they got at ordinary polling stations, and

24:31

it was precisely through these electronic polling stations

24:34

— each of which had 4,000 people

24:36

who supposedly voted — that there was

24:38

straight ballot-stuffing. They stole victory from

24:43

Roman Yuneman in District 30 — they stole it from him,

24:45

even though he wasn’t originally a Smart Voting candidate,

24:47

but we can see that by the

24:49

regular polling stations he won, and it was exactly

24:52

the 500 votes obtained through electronic

24:56

voting that took victory away from Yuneman. And in

25:00

Zelenograd, the CPRF (Communist Party of the Russian Federation) candidate

25:02

Ulyanchenko had victory stolen from him in exactly the same way through this

25:04

same electronic voting.

25:06

They stole the victory, and I once again demand

25:09

— and I’m glad that in the statement by the elected

25:11

deputies there was a direct

25:13

demand that this

25:15

electronic voting must be abolished. It is criminal.

25:16

If they keep electronic voting

25:18

in elections, then there will simply be no point at all

25:20

— I mean, it will lose any meaning to go

25:22

to elections, because some kind of black

25:24

box

25:24

— after all, they originally said there would be

25:26

electronic voting: you vote,

25:29

and then you’ll supposedly be able to check how your

25:31

vote

25:32

was counted. None of that existed. This thing just

25:34

popped up asking, “Who are you voting for?”

25:36

You vote there for Yuneman, Alyoshin, Zhukovsky,

25:38

and then the system just went — whoops — and said:

25:40

everyone voted for Rusetskaya. It was just

25:44

that kind of fraud, that kind of simply

25:47

blatant, shameless deception, frankly,

25:49

that no one even expected. I join

25:52

the demand to cancel all of this.

25:55

Of course, the victory over Ms. Khamzaeva

26:00

was gratifying.

26:00

That really turned out well, and it was

26:03

a pretty nerve-racking story for all of us,

26:05

because in the last

26:08

three days before the vote

26:09

we had to make Smart Voting somehow

26:12

get the word out to everyone around and

26:15

get them to vote for candidate Yandiev,

26:17

who had neither the time to run

26:19

much of a campaign, especially since

26:20

Khamzaeva from United Russia had become

26:22

such a symbol. I mean, she was literally

26:25

everywhere, on every corner, and she was

26:29

of course absolutely sure of her victory.

26:31

Yashin wasn’t allowed to run, and the Communists,

26:34

who pose a threat in Moscow,

26:36

more than anyone else, were kept out too.

26:37

They weren’t allowed in, so everything seemed guaranteed.

26:40

Yandiev, in no way, in anyone’s view,

26:44

could pose any threat. And yet we see Yandiev

26:49

here now — from A Just Russia (a Russian political party),

26:52

but nevertheless, first of all, he himself

26:54

really proved to be a solid guy. He

26:55

put out a statement saying, “I’m going to support everyone here,

26:58

I’ll be a deputy for everyone,”

26:59

and people looked at

27:02

him and said, “All right, we’ll vote for this

27:04

Yandiev.” Yashin endorsed him, he

27:05

did well, and Khamzaeva lost — and that was

27:09

great. But even better was that, as

27:11

Vika Tsyganova later said,

27:14

it turned out United Russia hadn’t actually needed

27:16

all that all this time, and all the trash that

27:18

was staged for her sake, it turns out...

27:21

There were attempts to throw a wrench in the works. Let's take a look.

27:23

A few seconds from the interview in Samara.

27:25

On the right is the AR channel... here it is in front of you.

27:28

They were clearing the field, and yet despite that...

27:32

No, that's not it.

27:33

That didn't happen, because in the end it simply...

27:36

In order to support someone.

27:38

They voted for this person.

27:39

...for him, whom, I'm sure, the majority...

27:42

...of those who voted for him had never heard of before that.

27:44

Maybe it wasn't worth taking part in this.

27:46

Valery, wait, you just...

27:49

...described the situation as if, for my sake...

27:53

...they were clearing the field for me. I believe that...

27:55

Everything you've just...

27:56

...listed was not clearing the field.

27:59

It was putting spokes in the wheels, and if that hadn't...

28:02

...happened, then I think the probability of our...

28:04

...victory would have been much higher.

28:08

What astonishingly brazen people, honestly.

28:12

They threw everyone out of the election, and handed her...

28:15

...what was it, 20 million rubles or so?

28:17

They spent it on Yashin's election campaign.

28:19

They kept him in jail until the very last day, and so...

28:23

And it turns out all of that was just obstacles...

28:24

...put in the way. Well then, she should have said so directly.

28:26

She should have said: I demand that Yashin be allowed to run, I...

28:29

...demand that the Communist candidate not be removed, I...

28:32

...will come to the debates. But she refused those...

28:34

...debates, even though Sobol had challenged her to them.

28:37

She refused, and now it turns out that of course...

28:40

...she would have won.

28:41

But evil United Russia was getting in the way.

28:43

It kept throwing obstacles in the way, and once again we...

28:45

...end up in a situation where this government...

28:47

...of disgusting crooks and thieves is simply...

28:50

...plague-ridden — the United Russia people are like plague carriers, and from them...

28:52

...everyone should run away. And all these various...

28:54

...people from Samara.

28:55

These are the kind of people who, with their...

28:58

...shifty little faces, are trying to figure out...

29:00

...which way they need to run.

29:02

They should all be running away from United Russia.

29:05

That's very important, and you and I will be working on that.

29:07

The funniest thing is, I talked about this...

29:10

...in my main video, and...

29:11

...this is now the most interesting...

29:13

...thing: waiting to see what came of it.

29:15

Yes, of course, this is in the district where we elected...

29:17

...the fake Solovyov.

29:19

Remember? The district where...

29:22

...the real Solovyov was supposed to be blocked.

29:24

Now you can see in the photo — he wasn't...

29:25

...allowed in; he was jailed.

29:27

And there was basically nobody there at all. There was this...

29:31

...woman running named Tsvetkova.

29:33

And for some reason this woman was very important...

29:37

...to the mayor's office, and they removed everyone there.

29:39

There was a Communist candidate there, quite a decent one...

29:40

...Timur Bushaev, I think.

29:42

Now, because of this Bushaev — here he is...

29:45

...you can see him in the photo...

29:47

...he was the only one left, and then later this...

29:50

...he too was removed. So the entire CPRF (Communist Party of the Russian Federation) slate...

29:52

...was registered — I mean, you have to submit signatures...

29:54

...and yet he was removed on some completely...

29:57

...fake grounds. It was done solely...

29:59

...so that Tsvetkova would win, because...

30:01

...she can't win on her own, and there we...

30:03

...looked around and there was nobody: there was a fake...

30:06

...Communists of Russia candidate, a technical candidate...

30:07

...there was a United Russia candidate, and there was a lookalike of this...

30:10

...Solovyov, whom nobody had ever...

30:12

...seen in person, just in case Pavel...

30:14

...did end up being registered. So we...

30:16

...wrote, all right, under these circumstances...

30:19

...I want to do this, Slava:

30:21

We have to support someone, maybe...

30:24

...just for the joke of it, out of principle...

30:26

...the fake Solovyov. He tells us at night:

30:28

"All right, let's do exactly that." They...

30:31

...put up a double, so let's see...

30:33

...you reap what you sow. Honestly, it looked...

30:35

...like a kind of...

30:37

...adventurous stunt, because it's hard...

30:39

...to elect someone just by getting people to come and...

30:41

...simply, you know, as a kind of hidden gesture of defiance...

30:43

...with a fig in the pocket (a Russian gesture meaning covert mockery or defiance).

30:44

...vote over two days. And now...

30:46

...he's a deputy, and nobody can find him. Some...

30:49

...profiles are appearing, and his photo...

30:51

...has surfaced showing that he was at a meeting with...

30:53

...Miron.

30:53

But not a single interview, nothing. I hope...

30:55

...he knows how to speak, and I hope he knows how...

30:57

...to read and write.

30:58

Well, maybe he'll turn out to be completely...

30:59

...normal. We don't know. I won't be ashamed of...

31:02

...everything I've said somewhere if he turns out to be...

31:03

...normal. But there will be some...

31:06

...Moscow City Duma session, and we'll see. I'm sure...

31:09

...that more journalists will run to him...

31:12

...than to anyone else, because all of us are terribly...

31:15

...curious about whom exactly we ended up electing.

31:19

To wrap up on Moscow, I want to draw your...

31:22

...attention to the party Communists of Russia and...

31:25

...this special little community of crooks...

31:28

...that takes part in every election...

31:31

...for the purpose of stealing...

31:32

...a few percentage points from the CPRF, but...

31:35

...in Moscow...

31:36

...it was a tool of the mayor's office. They...

31:38

...nominated candidates in every district, 45 people in all, and...

31:41

...everywhere supposedly through signature collection.

31:44

And based on those completely fake signatures...

31:46

...the mayor's office registered them. And now...

31:50

...it turns out that — let's take a look — I...

31:55

...misled you: not 45 people. They actually put forward...

31:58

...31 people, and out of these...

32:00

...31 candidates right away...

32:02

...each of whom supposedly brought in 6,000...

32:04

...signatures, and they were told: what excellent signatures you have.

32:06

How many of them do you think...

32:09

...received at least 6,000 votes? Out of those 6...

32:13

...thousand signatures they were supposed to collect...

32:14

...the answer is two people. Two people.

32:18

All the others received fewer votes...

32:21

...than the number of signatures they supposedly submitted, which of course is yet another...

32:24

once again shows that the whole thing was somehow...

32:26

absolutely—I, absolutely, I’m a fake, and...

32:30

I very much hope that the newly

32:31

elected deputies of the Moscow City Duma will deal with this.

32:33

My congratulations.

32:35

Sergei Boyko—my, well, basically my

32:38

congratulations to the city of Novosibirsk, which

32:42

failed to remove

32:45

the mayor—United Russia–KPRF (Communist Party of the Russian Federation) man Lokot. But

32:49

still, Sergei Boyko received quite

32:51

substantial support, came in second place,

32:53

and won 18 percent of the vote.

32:55

We’ll also connect with him later today.

32:56

We’ll watch a funny video from a search raid—another

33:00

example of why you need to believe in yourself. Everyone

33:04

thought, like, Boyko won’t win, he has

33:08

no chance, so what difference does it make?

33:10

We just need to consolidate.

33:12

Instead of voting against Lokot for different

33:13

candidates,

33:13

now it’s clear that if everyone had

33:17

consolidated and voted

33:18

smartly, only for Boyko, and if just a little

33:21

more effort had been made to turn people out, then

33:23

Lokot would have lost. In fact, Lokot got

33:26

with all the administrative resources at his disposal only

33:28

51 percent of the vote, while all the other

33:30

candidates got 49 percent.

33:31

If we had united around Boyko, he

33:33

absolutely could have won the election too. This is

33:36

an absolutely realistic scenario, just

33:39

super realistic. There’s nothing here that should

33:42

make it seem like some kind of

33:43

impossible thing—to unseat the mayor

33:45

of a major city. Novosibirsk is the third-largest

33:47

city in the country—though, though, people always

33:51

argue with that statement in

33:52

Yekaterinburg, but formally it’s still third.

33:54

It was absolutely possible, and

33:57

as residents of Novosibirsk, I urge you

33:59

to keep working with Boyko. You’ll soon have

34:00

elections to the city assembly and so on.

34:03

Boyko is now the main opposition figure in Siberia.

34:06

He proved his support in the election.

34:08

He proved that he is Siberia’s leading opposition politician. Let’s

34:10

consolidate around him. I’ll wrap up

34:13

this topic with the rest of the country, because

34:15

I’ve seen comments like, well,

34:17

sure, Moscow, sure, St. Petersburg, and so

34:20

on—but in the rest of Russia,

34:22

Smart Voting worked. Smart

34:24

Voting worked much better than

34:27

in Moscow, for example in Mari El (a republic in Russia),

34:30

because in Yoshkar-Ola there was an outright

34:33

super-mega triumph of Smart Voting.

34:36

Let’s take a look at Yoshkar-Ola. Do we have

34:39

the graphic for Yoshkar-Ola? There were 32

34:41

United Russia members out of 35 there. The graphic is missing,

34:44

so I’ll just say it out loud, sorry

34:45

please, I’m repeating myself here,

34:47

technical difficulties. There were 32

34:50

United Russia deputies out of 35—that is, complete,

34:52

absolute domination by United Russia.

34:54

Now it’s 16 out of 35.

34:57

So we can see that the opposition, with the help of

35:02

Smart Voting—and of those 16, 12

35:05

people were Smart Voting picks—simply

35:07

came in and landed a solid blow against United

35:11

Russia in a place where it seemed, well,

35:13

good Lord, in Mari El you just couldn’t

35:15

break through—and yet they did. The same thing

35:17

happened in Birobidzhan: there were 18 United Russia members out of 21,

35:21

now it’s 10, and we got 11 opposition candidates elected.

35:25

Of those, 7 were Smart Voting picks. In Penza,

35:27

United Russia was simply

35:31

crushed, I’d say. There it had 32 out of 35,

35:34

that is, an absolute majority, and

35:36

now they’ve reduced the number of

35:38

seats to 25, and 15 of them are opposition-held, so

35:42

that’s a majority. Of those 15, 9 are Smart Voting

35:44

candidates. So in that sense,

35:46

big city, small city—

35:48

in a small city it works even better.

35:50

And of course our task is

35:54

to bring people together. We need to make sure

35:56

that several million people join the Smart Voting

35:57

system. If we do that,

36:00

again, it comes down to believing in ourselves.

36:02

As for United Russia taking a hit—St. Petersburg, you

36:05

all keep asking me about St. Petersburg.

36:07

I can’t say the same clearly about St. Petersburg,

36:10

because nobody knows what’s happening there.

36:12

Well, that is—rather, the only thing we do know

36:14

is that some kind of outrageous chaos is happening in St. Petersburg,

36:16

something monstrous.

36:17

But what the election results actually

36:21

are is quite hard to say. This chaos

36:23

is confirmed by a rather amusing recording

36:26

from one of the polling stations.

36:28

The chair of the commission wanted to call

36:30

the higher election commission, but his phone had died,

36:32

so he asked an observer for a phone. The observer

36:34

simply turned on a recording, and now we have

36:36

a phone conversation showing how

36:38

the commission chair—in the Admiralteysky District

36:41

of St. Petersburg—

36:41

was talking to the higher-ups...

36:42

[inaudible] sit and listen [inaudible]

36:48

for another 20 minutes, but here he shouted a couple of

36:51

necessary things—how long can we keep stalling?

36:53

What are they even making up over there...

36:57

[inaudible] some kind of hypothesis...

37:09

it’ll work out.

37:13

We have only called, what, fewer than

37:20

12—three of them, or maybe only four,

37:23

have submitted the protocol, while everyone else

37:27

hasn’t yet been given the go-ahead.

37:29

So what happened in St. Petersburg overall

37:32

was that Smart Voting candidates and

37:35

opposition candidates in general

37:36

simply won across the city, overwhelmingly.

37:40

After that, they simply

37:43

won all the municipalities. And

37:45

municipalities in St. Petersburg have

37:47

much greater power and much larger

37:49

budgets than in Moscow. And United

37:52

Russia—not even United Russia as such,

37:54

but the small-time United Russia people sitting there...

37:57

And the people who run these districts siphon off funds

37:59

for themselves—tens of millions.

38:01

They carve up the budget and hand it out to their relatives.

38:03

They simply started brazenly rewriting the election results

38:06

and are still rewriting them now.

38:09

It is literally Thursday now, and the voting was on

38:12

Sunday. In St. Petersburg, all of this is still going on.

38:15

In many municipalities, the final

38:17

election results still have not been announced, and the internet was simply

38:19

flooded with all sorts of absolutely

38:22

outrageous footage—almost like entertainment, except it is infuriating.

38:23

entertaining

38:24

videos—for example, one showing how, over there,

38:27

at Morskaya Zastava, at the 41-second mark, they simply

38:29

count the votes, see that

38:31

they are losing, grab a stack of ballots

38:33

and run off with them. I mean, can you imagine?

39:18

The person is apparently laughing nervously—

39:20

this female observer—because, well,

39:22

there is a camera hanging right there in the commission room.

39:27

There is supposed to be special monitoring, and ballots

39:29

are absolutely not allowed to be taken out.

39:30

They count the votes, realize they have lost, and

39:32

simply carry off the ballots. And this is not an isolated

39:35

incident. We had several cases in Yekateringofsky.

39:37

Our Dasha and a big team were running there,

39:41

and she won. After that, the people

39:44

who were counting the votes

39:45

realized they had lost.

39:48

They said:

39:49

"Well, our workday has started,"

39:52

but they waited until morning, and then

39:55

they took all the ballots and said, "We are handing them over

39:57

to the local police officer for safekeeping," which

40:00

is completely impossible under the law. They

40:02

are required to count everything and record it all, then

40:05

submit it to the GAS Vybory system (Russia's state election database). Instead, they handed them over

40:07

to the local police officer and then drove off. After that,

40:10

the officer returned the ballots—but obviously

40:13

not the same ones.

40:14

The checkmarks were completely different, and this

40:16

is happening everywhere. There were also simply

40:18

attacks and beatings of election commission members.

40:20

There is a video you have most likely already seen.

40:22

I want to show one more minute of footage—

40:24

absolutely disgusting footage of how one commission member

40:26

pressures another commission member,

40:29

how one member leans on another, and how

40:31

the police react to it. One minute.

40:58

I feel sick—they just punched me in the stomach.

41:02

Very, very hard. These are your colleagues—your

41:05

people saw it. I am asking you for help.

41:10

I was just punched in the stomach.

41:14

I am a commission member with advisory voting rights.

41:16

I was just punched in the stomach.

41:18

It hurts very, very badly. It was all recorded—right

41:20

there, on the cameras. Everything was absolutely

41:22

seen. Please take action.

41:26

This too, this too—just like the USSR (the Soviet Union).

41:35

The "cultural capital"—and at this polling station there was

41:38

ballot stuffing; at this polling station, victories were simply stolen.

41:41

Naturally, victories were stolen. But even so,

41:43

even now, if we look

41:45

at the rough figures I am about to give—

41:47

and they are very rough, because

41:49

everything is constantly being recounted and changing—

41:51

naturally, what we can more or less say now is this:

41:54

previously, United Russia members

41:57

held seats in all the municipalities of

41:59

St. Petersburg—around 1,400 people.

42:01

Now there are 900. So we

42:06

can see that roughly 500 people—and we

42:09

again, this is only approximate—we

42:12

estimate that 340 people backed by

42:15

Smart Voting managed to

42:17

break through all of this. In other words, there were

42:19

hundreds

42:20

of elected candidates whose victories were stolen from them. But even

42:23

in the middle of this trashfire, the victory

42:25

of Smart Voting, the victory of independent

42:27

candidates, was so significant that

42:29

340 people got through—340 people

42:32

broke through, and some municipalities

42:34

are even now completely under

42:37

the control of independent candidates.

42:38

That is great. It means everything worked.

42:42

And yes, for us, of course, that is great—but

42:45

I have been talking to you for so long, and the main

42:48

point is the victory of Smart Voting. As you understand,

42:52

we are celebrating here, while someone else

42:54

is very upset. And they

42:56

started getting upset much earlier than

42:58

we did. They have access to polling data, they

43:02

are very good at math, and

43:04

Putin's people, to our shame, have plenty of that. And we

43:07

have to admit that they realized

43:11

that Smart Voting is very dangerous

43:14

much faster than we realized

43:16

how powerful it is. Because all these

43:19

raids happened immediately before Smart

43:22

Voting in order to derail it. And now

43:25

what is happening is basically the largest

43:28

police operation in modern Russia.

43:31

Today there were more than 200

43:33

searches

43:35

in 41 cities across the country, all following exactly

43:38

the same pattern. A search is carried out—well, I

43:40

call it a search, but in reality it

43:43

could more accurately be called

43:45

a violent robbery or mugging, because

43:47

the goal is simply to come in and take away

43:50

all electronic devices.

43:51

And then the person's

43:53

bank cards are all blocked. In other words, they want

43:55

I am telling you here: let's get several

43:58

million people involved in Smart

44:00

Voting. And over there in the Kremlin they are sitting and

44:02

saying: they must not pull several

44:06

million people into Smart Voting, because

44:07

otherwise we are finished.

44:08

And absolutely everything must be done

44:11

to make sure they do not bring several million people

44:13

into Smart Voting. Their first step was

44:15

to smash our network of headquarters. That is exactly why

44:18

I am raising money through the link that you have

44:21

below in the description, so that we can still

44:23

stop them from destroying our system. And so they

44:26

carried out searches and seizures in every

44:28

at the office, then at each employee's home, and then at

44:32

the homes of those employees' parents

44:34

these searches, well, they really looked like—this

44:39

really looks like armed robbery

44:40

let's take a look at Chelyabinsk

44:46

such an insolent brute, you understand, he

45:13

pulled this mask over his face and thinks that

45:15

you'll never find him. We will find every last one of them

45:18

because in the police paperwork, everything

45:20

still shows who went where, which

45:23

unit was sent, so sooner or later

45:26

dear participants in all these searches

45:28

every one of you will be sitting in the dock

45:31

watching this video of how you

45:33

dragged someone by the leg there, crying and

45:36

saying, "Guys, I was forced to do it"

45:38

"I won't do it again, it was my

45:40

boss who made me do it"—that is what will happen

45:42

sooner or later. They're all young men, they

45:46

will all live long enough, and the statutes of limitations on all

45:49

these things will be lifted, because what

45:51

is happening, you understand

45:54

they declared all these donations illegal

45:57

funds and are carrying out searches over them

45:58

they break down doors, and how they were sawing through doors in

46:01

Vladivostok

46:04

that's Chelyabinsk again—oh, sorry

46:08

sorry, we showed Chelyabinsk again

46:10

let's look at how they were sawing through doors

46:12

in Vladivostok

46:32

[music]

46:41

in general, the actions of these people

46:43

who call themselves police officers

46:45

are in fact just some kind of thugs

46:47

their finest representatives of the citizens of

46:50

Russia—they really do look very much like

46:52

the actions of

46:53

you know, occupiers fighting partisans

46:55

the way it was shown in films—that is exactly how they

46:58

behave. Let's watch

47:00

or rather, let's listen for a minute and a half to the coordinator of

47:02

our Vladivostok штаб (campaign office)

47:04

telling how they forced her to undress

47:07

a woman officer, supposedly—the only one allowed

47:09

to conduct a personal search, although

47:11

it's unclear why anyone needed to undress

47:14

during a search in the department for combating money laundering

47:17

the anti-money-laundering department

47:20

they made her undress, and then

47:22

male police officers walked around as if

47:24

nothing was wrong. For a minute and a half they

47:27

were searching for my personal phone

47:30

I was trying to stay calm

47:37

to see exactly what they had managed to hide

47:48

and in the safe, where there was a postcard and my personal

47:51

diary. During the interrogation, I was asked whether

47:56

I knew Navalny and Volkov

47:59

whether I knew the Doctors' Alliance and the Teachers' Alliance

48:02

things like that, even what these organizations

48:05

actually do. Naturally, the first charge

48:08

Guys, hi everyone, but all my things

48:13

that they took—I understand that they

48:15

will be sent to Moscow, and I probably won't see them again

48:21

the host says: some kind of madness—they went in there

48:24

so, I undressed, and this woman asked me

48:27

to take off my bra. I took it off, and she

48:30

started feeling it over, as if God forbid something

48:32

might be sewn into it. Then this

48:36

guy walks in—and the main thing is, you're standing there

48:37

with this crazed look in his eyes, like he might

48:40

you know, corner you or start barking orders at them

48:43

waving documents around, and there I was, standing there

48:47

without a bra. How could they allow that?

48:52

The authorized female officer just stood there

48:54

and didn't say a single word on my behalf

48:56

that men weren't supposed to be there while a woman was being searched

49:00

you understand, these are just absolutely

49:03

brazen swine who demonstratively

49:06

behave like occupiers on our land

49:09

really, like occupiers on our land

49:11

this whole business with the searches

49:14

was absolutely

49:17

massive. That's exactly why I have no

49:19

slightest doubt that this was simply

49:21

personally ordered by Putin. This was

49:24

planned at the level of the Security

49:25

Council

49:26

200 addresses across the country, and everywhere

49:29

at exactly 6 a.m.—that is, in

49:31

Vladivostok at 1:00 p.m.

49:34

while in the European part of the country, where

49:36

it was 6 a.m. Moscow time—even the police

49:39

the National Guard, the Investigative Committee

49:41

interagency coordination—meaning

49:44

of course this operation

49:47

was organized personally by Vladimir Putin

49:50

who is suffering because his party,

49:52

United Russia,

49:55

got hit hard by us in these elections, and will keep getting hit

49:58

going forward. Let that party

50:00

of United Russia suffer. But what is striking, you know, is

50:03

really how much effort they once again put into

50:06

showing that Putin personally

50:07

controls all of this, how meticulously

50:09

for example, our coordinator from Kurgan also

50:12

says that at his

50:13

parents' home in a village—those who've been to Kurgan

50:15

will know, and those who haven't: I never did make it to

50:17

Kurgan, for which I constantly apologize to

50:20

the residents of that city. I even had

50:22

a meeting planned there, but frankly

50:24

it's far away, it's a fairly

50:26

remote region. It's not in Siberia, somewhere

50:28

else, but still remote. So

50:29

they even

50:30

went to search the home of the parents of

50:33

a coordinator who live two and a

50:35

half hours' drive from Kurgan, in a village

50:38

let's listen

50:39

My name is Alexei Shvarts, and I am the coordinator of Navalny's штаб (campaign office)

50:41

in Kurgan. I work at the office

50:43

because I hate

50:45

crooks, and today OMON riot police came to me and my loved ones

50:46

with bags, personally to me

50:49

They arrived early in the morning, they sawed through

50:51

the door to the house and burst in. The police acted as if

50:53

there was simply nowhere to step, and they

50:55

seized all the equipment, bank cards, cash, and

50:57

All my notebooks as well. OMON (Russian riot police) and the police

51:02

came to my parents' house in

51:04

the village, which is only

51:06

two and a half hours from the city, and they didn't think twice about making the trip.

51:08

They came, they searched everything, they

51:11

went through the bathhouse, even the shed,

51:14

went down into the cellar, looking for something,

51:16

though it's unclear what. They frightened my

51:19

mother so badly that she fainted.

51:21

But these actions won't scare me.

51:23

I will continue fighting this, these methods of

51:26

the authorities.

51:28

Well done, Alexei Shvarts, and well done to all our

51:31

coordinators. We had quite a

51:33

lively exchange of messages with them, with

51:36

everyone.

51:36

So far, no one has been scared. On the contrary,

51:39

everyone is just angry, fired up, and

51:40

of course, for some time

51:43

life will be quite difficult, because, well,

51:45

for all of them, and for some even for

51:47

their parents, their bank cards have simply been blocked.

51:49

That means, first of all, everyone has had

51:52

their money taken away. I remember somewhere in

51:54

Vladivostok, a fairly large amount of

51:55

money was taken away—someone's savings. He

51:57

had been saving for a very long time.

51:59

For a car he was planning to buy, or

52:01

for an apartment—they took from him something like 10,000 or 20,000

52:03

US dollars, like from our Vitalik

52:05

the cameraman in Moscow. He sold

52:07

an apartment, and he has documents showing that

52:10

he sold the apartment, but all that money

52:11

was taken away, just like that.

52:13

Maybe, say, a young man brings

52:17

a certificate saying, "I

52:18

bought this currency from the bank," and they tell him:

52:21

"No, now we're taking all of this away,

52:23

seizing it just like that." A personal bank card

52:26

is blocked, meaning you can't receive

52:27

your salary, you can't send money to anyone,

52:30

you can't pay for anything. It's a fairly

52:33

serious problem, and our entire

52:34

structure is, of course,

52:36

in limbo right now.

52:38

We don't fully understand yet how we will

52:41

rebuild it from scratch, but we

52:44

absolutely, definitely

52:46

will rebuild it.

52:49

You see that wonderful link—if you

52:52

go there, you'll help us. Billions are being

52:55

entered there precisely in order to

52:57

block a person's account. How does it

52:59

work? If they want to block

53:00

your account, the bank basically puts a negative balance on it, saying that you

53:04

owe money. You may have 10,000 rubles (about 10,000 RUB) in your account,

53:06

but it will show that you owe 75

53:08

million. You see, for example, one of our

53:11

people had a billion blocked on his account.

53:14

He's a coordinator of our headquarters, and

53:16

they blocked a billion—a negative one billion—so

53:19

in order for your account to be

53:20

unblocked, you would have to deposit 1

53:22

billion and 1 ruble. Sergei Boyko,

53:25

who came in second in the election in

53:28

Novosibirsk, certainly amused us with a video

53:31

from the search of his home.

53:34

Let's watch a few seconds of it now.

53:37

It was important for him to preserve certain

53:40

electronic storage devices. Let's see

53:42

how Sergei Boyko, a resourceful

53:44

man—people didn't vote for him for nothing. They

53:46

should have voted for him in even greater numbers.

53:46

How did he solve this problem?

53:49

Hi, friends, this is a drone with hard

53:54

drives.

53:55

Very important ones, containing all the valuable digital

53:59

information. And why is it flying, you may ask?

54:01

Because people have come with a search warrant.

54:04

The police have arrived. Right now we're sending off the most

54:06

important thing, and after that we'll get back to

54:08

the discussion. Well, clever idea, I have to say.

54:14

You can't deny that. But you know, I kept

54:18

seeing in the morning reports saying

54:21

there were searches in 10 headquarters, 20 headquarters, 40

54:24

headquarters, then 150 headquarters, 150 searches. I

54:28

texted Volkov

54:29

who was sitting there monitoring everything: "Are

54:31

you sure you're not mixing anything up? 150 searches? That

54:35

can't be right. Nothing like that has ever happened before.

54:36

You simply can't pull off an operation like that across

54:39

the whole country, and coordinating it

54:40

would be difficult.

54:41

He wrote back: "150 is the minimum." And then

54:45

it turned out there were around 200. We still don't

54:47

know the exact number.

54:48

There have truly never been operations on this scale—not against terrorists, not against

54:53

drug traffickers, not against corrupt officials.

54:55

There have never been operations of this scale

54:58

at any point, ever. And how can one not

55:01

recall the remarkable words of Dmitry

55:04

Medvedev, who explained why

55:07

the topic of corruption never really leads to

55:09

any searches, because

55:12

one party has basically claimed that issue for itself.

55:13

And as for the commission

55:20

on combating corruption,

55:21

I can say only one thing: this is a matter

55:24

for, of course, the leadership of the State

55:26

Duma. That is my opinion.

55:29

Dear friends, do not give up this

55:31

position, because this is the most fertile

55:35

issue, and you yourselves know that perfectly well.

55:38

Make sure that the fight against corruption

55:41

is led by United Russia in the

55:42

State Duma. Otherwise, the

55:45

number of reproaches about the

55:47

concentration of crooks and other

55:50

unreliable elements will only

55:52

grow. You need to deal with this yourselves.

56:02

You need to deal with this yourselves—and they do.

56:04

I really liked that in the front row there were

56:06

people sitting there—Vorobyov from Moscow

56:08

Region, Surkov—these are all major

56:11

corrupt figures.

56:12

They need to deal with it themselves, and they are.

56:14

And that's why they are carrying out these raids on our

56:17

What they actually have there is some kind of

56:19

There seems to be some kind of elaborate grand plan for a crackdown.

56:22

As for us in particular, there is this rather

56:23

amusing commission for combating

56:26

foreign interference, which has already

56:27

been given its first assignment on combating

56:30

foreign interference in the elections, and

56:31

it turns out that the people interfering in the elections were me and

56:34

Lyubov Sobol.

56:35

There was a very funny speech there.

56:38

By Zhirinovsky, though of course it was in that usual kind of

56:40

still, it ended with the fact that

56:43

the commission officially said: now we will consider

56:46

this—the State Duma is considering

56:47

the question of whether Sobol and I

56:51

organized interference in the Russian

56:53

elections. Let’s watch it—1 minute 14

56:54

seconds.

56:55

You just can’t sort yourselves out.

56:58

You’re creating an opposition for yourselves.

57:00

You’re creating your own gravedigger, just like they created

57:05

for the Democrats. They’re all over the place, and you’re building it up around

57:09

Lyuba, whipping her up so that she

57:12

takes the place of Navalny, Bolotova, and so on—and you did it yourselves.

57:14

Why did you start banning them?

57:16

It’s against the nation. Let them do it—I’ve said a hundred times

57:18

in the Kremlin:

57:19

let them walk around and shout whatever they want.

57:22

Eventually they’ll stop shouting and talking. But no—you

57:24

arrest them, hit them across the back with batons, and make things worse.

57:27

Last time you didn’t do anything

57:28

but make Lyuba into some kind of

57:30

You keep talking about some powerful Lyuba,

57:33

all day long. What Lyuba is this?

57:39

The Constitution, Klitschko, a sex symbol—

57:43

they keep throwing all this at him, so what is he supposed to do with it?

57:45

Once you’ve let it all out, you can’t stop it.

57:47

It was that girl, the activist—Lyuba, that is,

57:51

Sobol. Sobol is probably Navalny’s

57:53

mistress.

57:54

Let’s instruct the commission to

57:57

study all these issues. You were saying

57:59

that Navalny was recruited at Yale

58:02

University—let the commission look into it.

58:05

There.

58:06

Lyuba—let this Lyuba sort it out.

58:09

The commission.

58:10

50,000 people were watching live.

58:13

It was a funny speech, really funny.

58:15

A funny speech, and it seems like nobody really

58:17

looks at Zhirik (Vladimir Zhirinovsky’s nickname) as anything more than a kind of funny

58:19

old man saying all sorts of ridiculous things about Lyuba,

58:21

whipping her up, and yet in the middle of all that silliness

58:23

he was also saying some correct things: Lyuba

58:25

was whipped up—well of course, you

58:27

built her up for the elections and then didn’t let her run, while

58:30

arresting her endlessly and using violence—so what

58:32

is Lyuba supposed to do? Naturally,

58:34

she goes around campaigning against you.

58:36

But all of this ends with them, on the one hand,

58:39

sort of egging him on there,

58:41

fumbling around over who this Lyuba is and

58:42

saying, “Lyubasha Sobol,”

58:45

but it really ends with

58:48

an official procedural instruction being issued:

58:51

that Navalny was supposedly recruited at

58:53

Yale University, that the Marines were somehow swapped in—

58:55

let the commission check it.

58:57

The commission will be checking into it, and when this

59:00

commission sends me some letter

59:03

saying, “Please provide proof that

59:05

you are not a Marine,” I mean,

59:10

it’s all funny, but it will keep

59:13

growing and growing and

59:15

growing, and in fact it will affect

59:16

everyone in our country, because these people,

59:19

in their panic and in their fear of us,

59:23

of our coordinated action,

59:24

of our Smart Voting strategy, will

59:26

trash and destroy everything here—from

59:29

the economy to absolutely anything.

59:32

Just watch: right up until the elections to the

59:35

State Duma, these people will

59:37

keep pulling stunts like this and doing things like that.

59:40

You’ll remember my words later.

59:42

But our task is to remember that our

59:45

coordinated action is the most

59:48

important thing. Yury Dud is the new enemy

59:52

of the authorities.

59:54

Apparently he has even drawn some

59:56

attention away from me for now, and fortunately

59:58

there haven’t been any searches yet.

1:00:00

They’re threatening him with criminal cases—in

1:00:02

the literal sense, they’re saying that he

1:00:03

is opening the gates of hell, because Dud

1:00:05

has done terrible things. First of all, he

1:00:08

—terrible from the authorities’ point of view—

1:00:11

released a film. Everyone is praising it. I haven’t

1:00:14

seen it yet because I simply haven’t had

1:00:16

time, with the elections and all, but absolutely everyone

1:00:17

is praising it and saying it’s a wonderful film

1:00:19

about the events in Beslan (the 2004 school siege in North Ossetia), and naturally

1:00:21

they immediately accused him of

1:00:23

presenting the terrorists’ point of view, and already

1:00:26

saying a criminal case should be opened and he should be jailed for

1:00:28

that. But then this terrible Dud went even further

1:00:31

and did something outrageous: he spoke at the

1:00:34

GQ awards and said, basically, why

1:00:36

should we stay silent? We must speak the truth.

1:00:38

Let’s watch 45 seconds of Yury.

1:00:49

The next day, when

1:00:55

this was all happening—well, in batches, all over the place—

1:00:57

electoral.

1:00:58

I’m asking you to speak out, and it seems that

1:01:03

silence has already stopped being a virtue. Thank you.

1:01:06

Before

1:01:08

it means they can come to any house,

1:01:13

including one on Rublyovo-Uspenskoye Highway (an elite residential area near Moscow),

1:01:15

and if there’s no difference, then there’s no need to meet

1:01:20

lawlessness with silence—you have to confront it face to face.

1:01:24

And after the film about Beslan, after

1:01:29

this video, Dud has now become an even bigger, doubly

1:01:31

enemy, because

1:01:32

it would seem that Dud just came out and said

1:01:34

some obvious things, but he

1:01:37

broke that silence. You know, there’s this huge room full of

1:01:40

all these people,

1:01:42

at the GQ awards,

1:01:43

who basically all think the same thing.

1:01:46

They understand that this is lawlessness, that

1:01:48

it’s absolutely awful, but they all stay silent and

1:01:51

cower, and then suddenly someone walks out onto the stage

1:01:52

and says: no, I’m not going to keep quiet about this, I’m saying everything

1:01:54

and I’m doing just fine. And you can absolutely

1:01:58

say all of this too, and

1:02:00

it has the effect of an exploding

1:02:01

bomb, and the Kremlin is terrified that

1:02:05

tomorrow someone else might come out and say it,

1:02:07

and then someone else will say it too, and if

1:02:09

this whole little gang of nice but rather

1:02:13

cowardly people from all these awards and

1:02:15

events starts speaking up, then it will be

1:02:17

impossible to contain. And now Dud (Yury Dud),

1:02:21

really does look, in the eyes of our

1:02:23

authorities, like some spawn of hell. Let’s

1:02:26

take a look at what was brilliantly said about him—well,

1:02:29

I simply enjoyed listening to this.

1:02:31

My favorite, Vladimir Solovyov, said this

1:02:32

after the Beslan film (about the Beslan school siege). Let’s

1:02:34

listen. Dud cheerfully says that

1:02:36

the state is to blame for everything.

1:02:40

What a degenerate. He’d be better off advertising

1:02:44

Head & Shoulders—in that head of his, apart from

1:02:47

chemical elements and Procter & Gamble products,

1:02:50

nothing else has been found, that’s all.

1:02:53

A sports journalist, talentless as ever,

1:02:55

has now crawled into something else and is just spewing filth

1:02:57

little by little for three hours, with not the slightest

1:03:04

understanding of

1:03:05

why, how, and what really happened.

1:03:09

Look at those faces, just look at this

1:03:13

fatness, this scum—look at

1:03:17

this anti-dandruff crusader.

1:03:20

There’s zero empathy there. Who even is this, anyway?

1:03:27

They’re hyping up some nobody—what kind of

1:03:30

money is behind all this, who’s inflating it all? The very same

1:03:36

liberal creep is trying to push him to the top.

1:03:39

They don’t understand that by doing this, they are opening

1:03:44

the gates of hell.

1:03:47

Polished-up nobodies, vermin—the gates of hell.

1:03:52

Of the liberal creep.

1:03:54

So thank you, Yury Dud, for

1:03:58

driving Vladimir Rudolfovich (Solovyov) into

1:04:01

yet another state of ecstasy. We really

1:04:03

enjoy watching it, and if it triggers

1:04:07

Vladimir so badly, then Dud is doing

1:04:10

everything right. Many thanks to him.

1:04:12

To wrap up my program, I absolutely have

1:04:14

to talk about what

1:04:15

is happening in Buryatia, because it is

1:04:17

an excellent example of how truly

1:04:22

explosive the situation in the country is, and how much

1:04:25

this government, with great difficulty and only

1:04:28

through force, is keeping things under control.

1:04:31

What is happening in Buryatia? Well, on the face of it,

1:04:33

nothing at all seemed to foreshadow it.

1:04:35

There is a shaman who is heading to Moscow, and we

1:04:39

can laugh at that.

1:04:41

We do laugh—there’s nothing wrong with

1:04:43

laughing at some people, at

1:04:46

I don’t know, excessive religiosity or whatever. But

1:04:48

even so, if you look at

1:04:51

polling across Russia, you’ll see there is

1:04:54

a significant part of the population that

1:04:56

supports shamanism. A shaman is going to remove

1:04:59

Vladimir Putin from Moscow.

1:05:01

He has every right to do that. And amazingly, along the way

1:05:04

people began joining him

1:05:06

because he’s walking along and saying

1:05:08

some obvious things—about

1:05:10

justice,

1:05:11

about how badly things are organized in Russia,

1:05:13

about how this bad, evil

1:05:15

government needs to be driven out. It’s a kind of, you know, new

1:05:19

naivety. We like to talk about

1:05:21

a ‘new sincerity’ among hipsters, and among

1:05:23

shamans there is also this new

1:05:26

sincerity: I am going to cast him out. People

1:05:29

join him, and these people

1:05:31

simply started being jailed.

1:05:32

So Putin, with all his

1:05:34

National Guard and everyone else,

1:05:36

was horrified to see that somewhere out there,

1:05:39

in the middle of nowhere, this had already gone beyond the purely symbolic,

1:05:42

they were approaching Ulan-Ude, and

1:05:44

thirteen people had already joined him, and

1:05:46

Putin was already scared, stamping his feet,

1:05:49

already crying out: my God, save me from

1:05:51

this shaman—what if he really does

1:05:54

cast me out? Because Putin understands that he is

1:05:57

an accidental man, appointed by a drunken

1:06:00

Yeltsin and his thieving family,

1:06:03

and maybe, just maybe, they really could drive him out.

1:06:05

So they gave orders there to arrest him

1:06:08

and his supporters. At the same time,

1:06:10

mayoral elections were taking place there, and

1:06:13

a remarkable man was running,

1:06:14

Marhaev (Vyacheslav Markhayev), a senator from the neighboring

1:06:17

Irkutsk region. He is the only

1:06:19

senator who spoke out in support of the protesters.

1:06:21

A former police officer, a former OMON riot policeman,

1:06:24

he fought in Chechnya and was regarded as a hero there.

1:06:26

He had quite substantial support, but

1:06:28

naturally, the election was rigged.

1:06:30

Markhayev did not win, and in Buryatia

1:06:33

protests began, and people gathered there

1:06:38

in the square, and they refused to disperse.

1:06:40

They stayed there overnight. What

1:06:42

did the police start doing? Well, first

1:06:43

they began detaining some people, and

1:06:49

they even detained a deputy of the

1:06:51

People’s Khural (regional parliament), Tsyrenov, but he

1:06:53

was freed by the protesters right during the rally.

1:06:55

Let’s watch—it’s just three seconds.

1:07:51

Well, as you can see, it’s pretty hard to say

1:07:54

that there was any outside interference here.

1:07:55

These are simply genuinely outraged people—Buryats and

1:07:57

non-Buryats, local residents, residents of Ulan-Ude.

1:08:00

They are outraged by this trash

1:08:02

that is happening, and I like the fact that

1:08:04

they arrested some people who were here with

1:08:05

this shaman. Why? On what grounds should you

1:08:07

arrest them? Don’t they have the right to walk with

1:08:10

a shaman, or with anyone at all? Don’t they have the right

1:08:12

to walk down the road? They do—it’s their road to

1:08:15

Ulan-Ude.

1:08:15

Excuse me, Kremlin, but to fix this

1:08:18

He doesn’t consider the road his own, fine, let it be that way.

1:08:20

Let some beat-up vehicle stop out in the middle of nowhere there,

1:08:22

but if someone is walking along it who is

1:08:25

against Putin,

1:08:26

then suddenly it’s “our road, we forbid anyone from walking on it, we”

1:08:29

“will arrest everyone.” And so there,

1:08:31

the standoff continues. The people in the

1:08:33

square are not leaving, and the police there already

1:08:36

can’t use the National Guard (Rosgvardiya) so easily after all,

1:08:39

because they all live together there.

1:08:40

It’s not like in Moscow. First of all, there,

1:08:42

people don’t know each other, and secondly, from neighboring

1:08:44

regions they bus in their own National Guard units there.

1:08:47

Here, it’s the same people who live right there,

1:08:49

somewhere nearby, and everyone knows them, and basically

1:08:51

people can come up to them and,

1:08:53

for lack of a better word, confront them — their neighbors can.

1:08:56

They can say, “So you’re beating us,”

1:08:58

“hitting us with a baton in the square right now,”

1:09:01

“and you’re not the only one with a baton, so answer us,”

1:09:03

“please, for what’s happening.” And the police

1:09:06

at night already started simply using these kind of

1:09:11

special little axes, but men in civilian clothes,

1:09:13

obviously police officers,

1:09:15

ran over

1:09:16

with these little axes and started smashing up

1:09:19

those buses where, apparently, people had gathered

1:09:22

— people

1:09:23

who stayed overnight. So there in

1:09:25

Buryatia (a Russian republic in Siberia), they seem to have their own way of holding

1:09:27

protests: they protest during the day, and at night they

1:09:29

stay in buses. And then

1:09:31

unknown men with little axes attacked,

1:09:33

wrecked all those vehicles, and with the help of those

1:09:35

little axes started dragging people out of

1:09:37

the vehicles. The police then said that

1:09:39

they don’t have any little axes at all,

1:09:42

they are not part of their official

1:09:45

equipment, and they know nothing about it. Why is no one talking about this?

1:09:47

I’ll show you now 10

1:09:48

seconds with one guy who very clearly has something

1:09:50

that looks like a little axe. Let’s take a look.

1:10:00

They use them when they come here to carry out

1:10:07

searches. They all have huge numbers of these things,

1:10:09

the kind you can see in

1:10:11

the photograph — literally little axes,

1:10:13

axes they use

1:10:15

to break down doors, with which they

1:10:17

smash everything. So what we’re seeing here

1:10:20

is a situation where police officers are simply committing

1:10:24

openly illegal acts already. They

1:10:26

hide themselves, they put on masks — I mean,

1:10:29

if they wear masks at a rally, they still

1:10:31

usually don’t deny that they are police officers.

1:10:33

In Buryatia right now, what’s happening is simply

1:10:35

something completely, absolutely gangster-like

1:10:38

in that sense. And even

1:10:40

one of the Buddhist lamas came to

1:10:42

that Soviets Square (the central square in Ulan-Ude), and

1:10:43

incidentally, here is the lama — let’s

1:10:46

listen to what he says.

1:10:49

He says: when informed people like

1:10:51

Dmitry Kiselyov or Olga Skabeeva do harmful things like this,

1:10:53

on television, that’s one thing. But when our own

1:10:55

neighbors start lying to us, neighbors who support United

1:10:57

Russia, that is very bad, says

1:11:01

the Buddhist lama in the Republic of Buryatia.

1:11:04

My friends, this of course shows a very,

1:11:08

very important shift

1:11:11

that is happening across the whole country.

1:11:14

The impoverishment of people plus the total decay

1:11:18

of United Russia — this is leading, has led, and will lead

1:11:22

to various consequences. But right now

1:11:24

in Buryatia, they seem to have managed to disperse some people again,

1:11:27

to jail some people there,

1:11:29

to fine others somewhere, and things

1:11:32

like that. But we don’t know what will happen next, and

1:11:35

this government will bring our whole country to

1:11:39

enormous problems, because they do not

1:11:41

want to understand and do not want to accept

1:11:45

how sick and tired everyone is of them. They do not want

1:11:48

to understand or accept that there are no longer

1:11:51

people willing to put up with the idea that power

1:11:53

belongs to them.

1:11:54

Whether it’s 100 or 80 percent, they must

1:11:57

share power with this shaman, with this

1:11:59

lama, with this Markhaev (likely Vyacheslav Markhaev, a Buryat opposition politician), who

1:12:02

is running, with Boyko, who is in

1:12:03

Novosibirsk. There are huge numbers of us in

1:12:06

Moscow too. Once again, the majority of those who came

1:12:10

to vote

1:12:11

voted against United Russia

1:12:14

candidates. What does that mean? We are the power here.

1:12:18

That is, we are the majority. We are different people.

1:12:20

There were CPRF candidates, Yabloko candidates, and others,

1:12:22

but all of us are not United Russia, and we demand

1:12:26

our unconditional participation in this

1:12:28

government. Guys, once again, congratulations on the

1:12:31

great success

1:12:32

of Smart Voting. We need to bring as many people as possible into this

1:12:35

voting effort,

1:12:37

and now that we have started to believe in ourselves,

1:12:40

we must convince everyone else to believe

1:12:43

in themselves too, so that we know how many of us there are and how

1:12:46

close our victory really is, and that

1:12:49

to oppose us, they need more than just these

1:12:51

these

1:12:52

idiots in masks running around and

1:12:55

sawing at some doors. There may be

1:12:57

a few thousand of them, but there are 3 million of us.

1:12:59

So we will definitely win. Thank you

1:13:01

very much to everyone who watched my program.

1:13:02

Until next time. It’s possible that next

1:13:05

Thursday I’ll miss it, because we simply need

1:13:07

to sort out a whole bunch of

1:13:09

technical problems here. But in any case,

1:13:10

we’ll stay in touch. Thank you very, very much

1:13:12

to everyone, and goodbye.

Original