Text version
0:02

On September 8, 2019

0:44

elections will be held

0:45

to the Moscow

0:54

City Duma.

0:57

I can't force you to do anything,

1:00

but I can try to persuade you.

1:01

If I want you, right now,

1:03

to go and sign in support of independent

1:05

candidates

1:06

and then, on September 8, at the election,

1:09

vote against United Russia.

1:11

Well, that means in this video I have to

1:13

provide a sufficient number of

1:14

arguments in favor of doing that, and

1:17

it's impossible to just make yet another

1:20

investigation about yet another United Russia politician.

1:22

If I'm calling for a major campaign

1:25

against all of United Russia, then I need to take

1:28

the leader of this party in Moscow, where the main

1:30

elections will be held, and use his example to show

1:33

why his party does not deserve

1:36

a single vote. And right now, together with

1:39

my colleagues from the Anti-Corruption Foundation

1:41

(FBK), I will do exactly that, and I will begin my

1:43

story here, in a place so close

1:47

dear and native to this representative

1:50

of the ruling party. His heart is here, here are

1:52

his family, and here is his money.

1:54

Welcome to the Golyanovo district.

1:57

[music]

2:18

Well, almost Golyanovo.

2:20

Hi, this is Navalny, and these are candidates for

2:23

seats in the Moscow City Duma, and

2:25

today, all together, we'll convince you that we

2:28

first need to put our

2:30

signatures behind these candidates—and not

2:33

put it off, but do it right now—and then

2:35

join forces and throw the party

2:38

United Russia out of the Moscow parliament.

2:40

Here he is, the face of this party, the head of United

2:45

Russia in Moscow, deputy chairman of the

2:47

Moscow City Duma, and possibly the most influential

2:49

deputy in the Moscow parliament, elected

2:52

from the districts of Severnoye Izmaylovo, Golyanovo,

2:55

Vostochny, and Metrogorodok: Andrei Nikolaevich

2:57

Metelsky.

2:59

He personifies the Moscow Duma and

3:01

Moscow's party of power, and today we put before you

3:05

one simple question:

3:07

Should Metelsky

3:09

and people like him remain in their positions,

3:12

or on September 8, at the election, should he be

3:15

replaced by these deputies? And so, I didn't say for nothing

3:19

that he is not just a leader, but

3:21

the embodiment of United Russia. Deputy

3:23

Metelsky has held his seat for 18

3:26

years—four consecutive terms. Now he

3:29

wants to become a deputy for the fifth time, for

3:31

the next five years. And the funniest thing is that

3:35

the top United Russia figure in Moscow, the secretary

3:37

of the Moscow branch, a member of the presidium

3:39

of the general council, is running not

3:42

from the party he leads

3:44

but as an independent candidate.

3:54

Just like all the other

3:55

United Russia candidates in Moscow. They want to deceive

3:58

you by pretending to be independents. Let me

4:01

tell you a little about him. He is a

4:02

remarkable character, like practically

4:04

all the other United Russia politicians. For 18 years he has

4:07

headed the party of power in Moscow. That is,

4:09

he is a major regional

4:10

official with a status not much lower

4:13

than Sobyanin's. In theory, he should be

4:14

everywhere. But the problem is that Metelsky

4:17

simply does not exist in the public sphere.

4:19

He gives no interviews,

4:21

no comments to the media.

4:23

It's unlikely anyone has seen him walking around

4:25

courtyards and meeting with residents. He

4:27

has not reacted in any way to any of the pressing

4:29

issues on our public agenda—things like,

4:31

I don't know, protests in Moscow, the raising

4:34

of the retirement age, the notorious

4:36

renovation program, and so on. Well, maybe he is a

4:38

famous YouTube video blogger? And

4:40

actually, he does have a YouTube channel,

4:42

but it has 0 subscribers and only one

4:45

video view—and that was when I was

4:48

preparing this. And that's not surprising, because,

4:51

as they like to say in the Moscow city government,

4:53

of Moscow,

4:53

money loves silence. And that's exactly what I want

4:56

to talk about. How do you learn about an official's life,

4:58

what he lives on? Of course, from

5:01

his financial disclosure. I printed out Metelsky's disclosure.

5:04

On paper, he seems to have a decent income: 7

5:07

million rubles (about $110,000 at the time), but at the same time

5:09

he owns no property, no real estate—only

5:11

either official housing or rented accommodation.

5:14

No apartments, no cars. Maybe his wife is an

5:17

oligarch?

5:18

No, not that either. In 2018 she

5:22

earned 900 rubles a month (about $14 at the time).

5:24

All right, you can probably already guess

5:26

where this is going: a poor deputy, his whole life

5:28

in public service. Surely we won't find a dacha on

5:31

Rublyovka (an elite suburb outside Moscow) or a penthouse in central Moscow, right?

5:34

No, friends, this story is not only—and not even mainly—

5:36

about one particular deputy. Our

5:39

investigation is about power in general, about

5:42

the United Russia party, and about how

5:44

this system works.

5:46

If we turn on the television, we see these

5:49

people as ardent patriots who

5:51

swear their love for the motherland.

5:53

But in practice, they loot our

5:56

country and move billions abroad,

5:59

preparing backup airfields and a quiet

6:02

retirement for themselves

6:03

and their relatives somewhere far away. And so the

6:05

leader of Moscow's United Russia politicians, according to

6:07

official documents, is a poor

6:09

independent candidate, a servant of the people for more than

6:11

twenty years. But in reality he is one of

6:13

the richest residents of Moscow—a businessman,

6:16

a fraudster, a corrupt official, who

6:19

before the election hides behind a zero-profile image.

6:21

in his income and asset declarations, while in fact

6:23

he owns assets worth hundreds

6:25

of millions of dollars. And before we

6:27

show you what our United Russia politician has made off with

6:30

in his little beak, let’s get acquainted with

6:33

all the participants in our journey.

6:35

Metelsky’s mother, Eldebita Vasilievna.

6:37

Metelskaya. She is 75 years old.

6:41

Andrei Andreyevich Metelsky. Yesterday he

6:44

turned 26.

6:46

And Metelsky’s main friend,

6:48

Pyotr Sergeyevich Ivanovsky.

6:51

This Ivanovsky, as he is called by

6:53

Metelsky, “my longtime friend,” was also

6:57

a deputy in the Moscow City Duma, then he became

6:59

vice president of the United Russia Support Fund

7:02

in Moscow—believe it or not, such a

7:03

fund exists. And now he is an adviser to the deputy speaker

7:07

of the Moscow City Duma—that is, to Metelsky himself.

7:09

He is listed on the website, and that is, basically,

7:12

the whole cast of characters that will concern us today,

7:14

because the scheme

7:16

is primitive to the point of absurdity. Now

7:19

let’s move from Moscow, where United Russia politicians

7:22

make money, to the notorious Europe

7:24

where our party of power loves

7:26

to spend it. We’re flying to Austria.

7:30

[music]

7:32

Welcome to Tyrol.

7:35

This is the very heart of Europe—the Austrian

7:38

Alps, places of incredible beauty.

7:41

Here, right here—not in some

7:44

Izmailovo, Metrogorodok, or

7:46

Golyanovo—he prefers to live and keep

7:49

his money.

7:50

United Russia politician Metelsky—his Austrian

7:52

life began much earlier than you

7:54

might think.

7:55

Twelve years ago, in 2007, when there were still no

7:59

sanctions, wars, or international

8:02

isolation, when Putin had not even yet

8:04

finished his second term,

8:06

and Moscow’s mayor was not Sobyanin but Luzhkov,

8:09

it was then, in 2007, that deputy

8:12

Metelsky made a key decision:

8:15

to stash everything he stole in Russia

8:18

abroad. How, where, and how much?

8:21

To answer these questions, we are

8:23

setting off on a little...

8:27

[music]

8:32

We are in an Austrian village called

8:35

Serfaus.

8:36

An amazing place, very beautiful.

8:38

See for yourselves. And it is here that Andrei

8:41

Metelsky proves that United Russia

8:43

is a party of action. If you found yourself in a place like this,

8:46

of course you would walk around, look at everything, and

8:49

say, “It would be nice to have a house here.”

8:52

But he doesn’t walk around and say it—he simply

8:53

goes ahead and buys.

8:55

That hotel over there—look how

8:57

nice it is: the four-star Hotel Maximilian,

9:04

with its own pool and spa area.

9:06

Metelsky paid 5 million

9:09

euros for it, even though at that moment he

9:11

had absolutely nothing to his name except

9:13

a deputy’s salary and his mother’s pension.

9:16

You can be sure that those five

9:19

million were far from the family’s last

9:22

savings. We continue our journey through the Metelskys’

9:24

Austrian holdings.

9:26

Fortunately, we won’t have to travel far—

9:28

or rather, we won’t have to travel

9:30

at all.

9:35

Alexei, where are we going? We already filmed everything in Metrogorodok.

9:38

Where are we going, Georgy?

9:40

Metelsky is a deputy from that district.

9:42

But in fact, we are filming

9:44

an investigation into the leader of this party in

9:47

Moscow. Do you seriously

9:49

think that such an important man

9:51

could have only one hotel in this

9:53

town? No. Exactly one year after

9:56

buying the first hotel, Maximilian, the

9:58

Metelskys decided to expand their holdings

10:01

with this building: traditional Tyrolean

10:04

architecture, a small hotel, and inside it

10:06

its own restaurant.

10:08

Let’s go in—no need to be shy.

10:10

Near the entrance, if you’ve been skiing

10:12

or just walking in the Alps and got tired, no

10:15

problem: the hospitable Andrei Metelsky

10:17

is ready to offer you the terrace of his

10:20

hotel restaurant.

10:22

He bought it for 3.5 million

10:23

euros. Again, it is unknown where he got

10:26

the money. But he bought it and enjoys this

10:28

property: a magnificent view, you sit there

10:31

drinking coffee,

10:32

while United Russia politician Metelsky collects the money.

10:35

And now let’s look at all this again from above. There,

10:37

on that terrace, I was just standing there—that is

10:39

the restaurant terrace, and above it

10:41

is, accordingly, the hotel.

10:43

And if we fly a little farther over

10:45

this mountain village, we will see how

10:47

close by Metelsky’s other hotel is.

10:50

There it is. And here are photos from

10:53

the social media of Metelsky’s wife, Tatyana.

10:55

They were taken right here, in Serfaus.

10:58

This New Year holiday, the Metelskys

11:00

spent in their Austrian hotel,

11:02

as they did dozens of weekends over the course

11:06

of the years. Of course, we would like to show you

11:08

more of these beautiful views, but we

11:10

really can’t linger, because ahead of us

11:12

there are still several more stops in

11:14

Austria. There’s no time to waste.

11:16

Yes, of course, we understand that deputy

11:19

Metelsky will tell us, “You know,

11:21

I understand, but it belongs to my mother, it belongs to my son.”

11:23

Indeed, he registered all of it in the names of his

11:26

very elderly mother and his

11:29

not-yet-fully-grown son. But the point is

11:31

that this is a simple scheme. For this

11:33

investigation, we did not need to uncover

11:35

any complicated offshore structures or anything

11:38

like that. It’s a simple setup there...

11:42

Russian individuals linked to Metelsky

11:44

set up Austrian companies. These

11:46

Austrian companies bought a large

11:48

amount of real estate, and the brazen simplicity

11:50

of this scheme once again shows the sheer audacity

11:52

of United Russia. In other words, he simply

11:55

doesn’t even think he needs to hide.

12:02

There is a monument on Tyrolean soil

12:04

to the little castling move. Remember September 24, 2011,

12:08

when Medvedev and Putin announced that

12:10

they were switching places and Putin would once again

12:11

become president?

12:12

United Russia was jubilant, practically squealing

12:14

with delight: “Putin is back, Putin is back!”

12:17

And Andrei Metelsky was shouting and applauding

12:19

louder than anyone else.

12:20

And then, three days later, on the 27th, somehow, from who knows where,

12:23

he got 7 million euros and bought this

12:26

hotel in the Alps—his third one already. We’re

12:28

flying over a mountain river and

12:30

approaching Metelsky’s third hotel,

12:33

Mozart.

12:34

It’s a traditional Tyrolean hotel.

12:36

At the level of the fifth floor, sticking out of the hotel,

12:39

is a strange-looking pipe, and our

12:42

theory is that

12:43

the other end of the pipe was plugged directly into

12:47

the budget of the city of Moscow

12:48

to make it easier for United Russia

12:51

to siphon money out of the country. Though, of course, it

12:54

could also just be a waterslide.

12:56

Tennis courts, a football field, a swimming pool—

12:59

it’s fun and great here at any time of

13:01

year.

13:02

I really hope you’re not tired of

13:04

Austria yet, because you and I still have

13:07

another 600 kilometers (about 373 miles) to go to Vienna, where

13:11

Metelsky has yet another property.

13:16

[music]

13:18

We stopped at a gas station to grab

13:21

some coffee because, honestly, we’re

13:22

pretty damn sick of driving all across

13:24

Austria. If you drove several hundred

13:26

kilometers in search of the real estate of a United Russia

13:29

big shot, it would be funny if

13:32

all Muscovites knew just how much he owns

13:35

here, from Tyrol to Vienna.

13:37

Though they probably wouldn’t

13:39

vote for him after that. So not funny—

13:41

fair enough. I hope that many

13:44

millions of Muscovites learn about

13:46

this man’s real estate from our

13:48

video. So if you’re watching it,

13:51

share it, subscribe—

13:54

and by the way, we can also

13:57

drive up to Metelsky’s next hotel,

13:59

walk over, and sort of smear something on the

14:01

door handle and watch the reaction

14:04

of his assorted staff.

14:11

We’ll be right here.

14:19

[music]

14:24

Girl 1

14:29

[music]

14:37

The hotel and palace here are

14:40

a historic building. Now let me

14:42

tell you a little about it. Remember how

14:43

World War I began? Sarajevo—

14:46

the Austrian archduke was assassinated, and the Austrians

14:48

presented the Serbs with an ultimatum that was deliberately

14:50

impossible to fulfill. They didn’t fulfill it,

14:52

and that, essentially, is how the war began.

14:54

The famous July Ultimatum was

14:56

signed in this very building. It is

14:58

historic.

14:59

And nearby there’s a staircase; now we’re going to

15:01

walk along it. It’s historic too,

15:03

known to every resident of Vienna; people have even

15:06

written poems about it.

15:07

By the way, while we’re heading to the staircase, I

15:09

also want to say that this same building

15:11

hosted the famous arms-control negotiations

15:14

between the USSR and the USA. It’s a very

15:17

historic building; so much has

15:19

happened here. Naturally, at one time

15:22

the palace belonged to members of the royal

15:24

family, but now this entire complex—the palace,

15:27

the hotel, and the surrounding

15:29

grounds—belongs to the Russian aristocracy.

15:32

The head of United Russia in Moscow,

15:34

Andrei Metelsky, bought all of this

15:36

for 13 million euros. Look

15:39

at this amusing detail: you know how on

15:41

hotel facades they very often hang

15:43

different national flags?

15:44

This hotel was bought with money stolen

15:47

in Russia and taken out of Russia, and yet here we see

15:49

here

15:49

the American flag, the European Union flag, the French

15:52

flag, the Italian one, I think—

15:54

but no Russian flag. How can that be, Deputy Metelsky?

15:56

Well, Milov promised that we

15:59

would fly to Austria, but in the end, for some reason,

16:01

only Alexei went there. Well, that’s because you’re

16:03

the candidate—you’re supposed to work in the field,

16:05

while I took on the hardest part

16:07

of the job. Guys, you can’t imagine how

16:09

painful, truly painful, it was for me to look at all

16:11

these Austrian palaces built with

16:13

money stolen in Russia. But let’s

16:16

sum up the financial results of this Austrian

16:18

story. In total, about 40 million euros were invested

16:21

in Austrian hotels.

16:24

By Metelsky himself,

16:26

his pensioner grandmother, a 19-year-old young man, and

16:30

some deputy who, at that

16:32

time, let’s say, was earning maybe two

16:34

million rubles. And by the way, from the financial

16:36

statements we learn that later

16:38

Metelsky and company poured another 12 million

16:41

euros into this business—that is, they effectively took money out of

16:44

Russia and invested it in Austria.

16:47

Well, we’ve already looked at Austria, but if anyone

16:50

thinks that Metelsky wasn’t also trying

16:52

to make money off construction and real estate in Moscow,

16:55

they’re mistaken. And now you’re going to see

16:57

the most astonishing part of our

17:00

investigation,

17:00

from which you’ll learn how Metelsky and his

17:03

his mother receives hundreds

17:06

of millions into her accounts. Here we are flying over a huge

17:08

plot in central Moscow, in Zamoskvorechye

17:11

right on the embankment of the Moskva River — prime

17:14

land not far from Paveletsky Station.

17:17

In 2014, they decided to build here

17:20

a hotel and serviced residential apartments.

17:24

As you can clearly see, there is no hotel at all, but

17:26

according to the plan, by 2021 buildings will be erected here

17:30

with a total area of 14,500 square meters

17:33

(about 156,000 square feet), and by that time it will all be completed.

17:35

By then, the nearly 80-year-old mother of the deputy

17:39

Metelsky will be the owner of this land.

17:42

Right now we are standing by the construction

17:44

fence. Behind it is a huge area where

17:48

at first glance, right now

17:50

absolutely nothing seems to be happening. From the standpoint

17:52

of the hotel project,

17:53

that is completely true. Development plans for

17:56

this site appeared in 2014.

17:59

They even began demolishing a building to clear the site,

18:02

but over the next several years, nothing

18:05

happened. Now the deadlines have been pushed back significantly.

18:07

On the Moscow City Hall website, you can

18:10

find the project listing for this construction site and the new

18:12

deadlines.

18:13

The new completion date is 2021. The developer listed there

18:17

is OOO Manor. This company formally

18:20

belongs half, but in practice entirely,

18:22

to

18:23

Lyubov Metelskaya. This company is what opened for us

18:27

a portal into the inexhaustible wealth of the

18:30

Metelsky family. We will definitely talk about

18:32

that a little later, but for now let's

18:34

see what else is here. We have reached

18:39

the only clearly functioning

18:42

building on the entire site: Kozhevnicheskaya

18:44

15. This building has great historical

18:47

value. It is included in nearly all

18:49

lists of Moscow constructivist landmarks.

18:52

Moscow.

18:52

That is thanks to this round frieze made of

18:55

majolica tiles, on which

18:56

Soviet ideals are depicted: harvesting,

18:59

athletes, and bathers. This used to house

19:02

the

19:03

Kozhevniki baths, and now it is a fitness center.

19:06

The historic building itself belongs

19:08

to Lyubov Metelskaya's company.

19:10

This is also the company's registered address.

19:13

Altogether, behind these fences there are 12,000

19:17

square meters of land ready for development. I

19:20

think many of our viewers are asking:

19:22

why was the hotel never built?

19:24

Why has a hugely valuable plot in central Moscow

19:27

been sitting idle for five years already, and

19:30

why will it remain idle for at least three more years

19:32

until 2021? I have an answer to that question,

19:37

and it is an astonishing example of how United Russia members

19:40

make money. In fact, Lyubov

19:43

Metelskaya takes money for the hotel

19:46

project, and then simply keeps that money

19:48

for herself. Listen, let's stop

19:51

talking about this unfortunate 75-year-old

19:53

woman. It's obvious to everyone that she has

19:56

nothing to do with this scheme. It's simply that

19:58

Metelsky brazenly and shamelessly

20:01

transferred everything into his elderly mother's name,

20:03

incidentally exposing her to serious legal

20:06

liability — effectively throwing her under the bus.

20:08

Practically anyone else in her place, if not for the fact that

20:11

Lyubov Metelskaya's son is a United Russia politician and

20:13

deputy, would already be in prison on economic-crime

20:15

charges. If you type into any search engine

20:18

the name

20:19

Lyubov Metelskaya — you don't even need the surname,

20:21

just type in "Lyubov" — then

20:24

you will find links to dozens of rulings by the

20:27

Moscow Arbitration Court. We

20:30

studied them carefully. These documents are unprecedented

20:33

in their content. The essence of the case

20:35

is simple: the "businesswoman"

20:39

Lyubov Metelskaya

20:41

decided to build a huge hotel in

20:43

central Moscow. But she chose to do it

20:45

not with her own money, but with money

20:49

from outside partners and attracted

20:51

investors.

20:51

They all invested large sums in her company

20:54

Manor, and then she simply took that money and

20:58

stole it — transferring it to her own personal account,

21:00

to the personal account of her son, deputy Metelsky,

21:03

and, as is classic in such cases, a large share

21:05

was moved offshore. Helping her do this

21:08

was Manor director Vyacheslav Kapustin. I would not

21:11

have mentioned him if not for

21:13

one amusing detail: he is Metelsky's neighbor

21:15

on the same stairwell, and also the son

21:17

of another Moscow City Duma deputy from Izmailovo,

21:19

Andrei Kapustin. And by the way,

21:22

Metelskaya's business partners

21:24

were, to put it mildly, not very pleased

21:26

with what was happening. Hence the numerous

21:28

court filings, and thanks to those

21:30

filings, we know this entire scheme in documented detail,

21:34

down to every account number

21:36

and every transfer.

21:38

We know the whole scheme, and by the way, these

21:41

details are very interesting. In total,

21:43

more than 1.4 billion rubles

21:45

(about 1.4 billion rubles) passed through Manor's accounts over time.

21:48

Of that amount, 270 million rubles were transferred

21:50

to the personal accounts of Lyubov and

21:53

Metelsky under various

21:54

investment agreements and loan

21:55

contracts. Another 305 million was transferred

21:59

personally to deputy Andrei Metelsky. Thus,

22:01

a total of 575 million rubles

22:05

ended up in the accounts of Moscow's chief

22:08

United Russia politician.

22:09

This is unbelievable. Am I understanding correctly that with

22:11

an official deputy's salary of 5

22:13

million rubles, Metelsky, together with

22:15

his mother, borrowed from their own company

22:17

nearly 600 million rubles, but

22:19

would have to repay it over 120 years

22:21

and would only finish repaying it in 2133? And let me remind you that

22:25

not a single kopeck of these hundreds of millions

22:27

rubles

22:28

Metelsky did not disclose this in his declarations.

22:30

He was moving enormous sums of money around, while

22:33

telling voters that he was an honest

22:35

deputy.

22:35

that he had nothing besides his salary. And here it is important

22:38

to emphasize one more thing: court

22:40

rulings have effectively confirmed that

22:42

these loans were fictitious and non-market, that they

22:44

were unsecured, and that the interest rates

22:47

on them were many times below market rates—and you would never

22:49

be able to get loans like that. And in fact,

22:51

the repayment terms were impossible to meet, and so essentially

22:53

the Moscow court—not even us,

22:56

but the court itself—effectively ruled that the chief

22:59

United Russia figure in Moscow

23:00

But that is not all. The remaining money

23:04

that was not siphoned off into fictitious

23:06

accounts by Metelsky was transferred to

23:09

a Cypriot offshore company—that is, $22 million

23:13

dollars, which comes to about 750

23:15

million rubles.

23:16

It was sent to accounts belonging to the family

23:18

on a Cypriot offshore account. And in court,

23:21

the director of Manara—the same neighbor of Metelsky

23:24

from the same landing in their apartment building—stated that

23:26

the money was moved to Cyprus allegedly in order

23:28

to purchase a neighboring plot of land.

23:31

But that is actually a lie, because

23:33

that plot was already in their

23:35

ownership. Or rather, not exactly that word—earlier, in fact,

23:37

this asset

23:39

to whose account the

23:41

$22 million was transferred at that very moment

23:44

owned the Venice hotel that Alexei had told us about,

23:47

and this whole transfer of $22

23:51

million looks very much like

23:53

Metelsky was, let's say it plainly, trying to steal

23:56

money from his partners. This should go straight onto

23:59

campaign leaflets. It should read something like:

24:01

"Sign for our candidate—he

24:03

borrowed 570 million and never paid it back.

24:06

United Russia—the party of real deeds.

24:09

An excellent candidate, a true

24:12

—or an independent candidate, of course.

24:15

An independent candidate backed by United Russia.

24:17

Friends, we've gotten so carried away with this

24:19

hotel story that we still haven't told even half

24:21

of it. Let's move

24:23

on. We took a close look at what else

24:25

belongs to Metelsky. We simply took

24:28

the legal entities register and looked through it,

24:30

made a list of all

24:32

directors, partners, nominees, and other

24:35

people involved in organizing this

24:37

underground business empire. The scheme

24:39

turned out not to be very complicated. These companies

24:41

that had at one time or another belonged to Metelsky—

24:44

he transferred them to two people, because formally

24:47

he is not allowed

24:49

to engage in business. These people are Flama

24:52

and Metelsky's friend and adviser in the Moscow

24:54

City Duma, Pyotr Ivanovsky. This is very

24:57

easy to discover and prove. We

25:00

took a list of 12 companies that

25:03

had at some point belonged to Metelsky

25:04

as property.

25:05

In 7 of them, the stake—down to the exact percentage—

25:08

was transferred to Metelskaya.

25:11

In 5, the stake was registered to Pyotr Ivanovsky.

25:14

There are simply no other people involved. Most

25:17

of their companies were registered at three

25:20

addresses, and all three premises belong

25:23

to Metelsky and his associates. Listen, it really looks like

25:26

they are not trying very hard to hide.

25:28

And it is enough simply to study

25:29

the combination of addresses and their owners to

25:32

learn a lot more interesting things. Behind

25:36

me is a huge construction site. Here they are

25:38

building the Lefortovo transport interchange hub.

25:40

Lefortovo.

25:41

These kinds of hubs are places where

25:44

metro lines, suburban trains, buses, and

25:48

trolleybuses all come together. And these transport

25:50

interchange hubs have become a signature

25:53

personal project of Sobyanin for Moscow. In

25:55

such places it is very profitable to develop

25:57

businesses: shopping centers are built here,

25:59

park-and-ride lots, because

26:01

the enormous passenger flow—hundreds of thousands

26:04

of people every day—guarantees huge

26:06

profits. So this particular

26:08

Lefortovo hub

26:10

is being built by the Metelsky family. We rise above

26:15

the impressive construction site. This is strange,

26:17

because Moscow Deputy Mayor Khusnullin

26:20

claimed that the hub would open in 2018,

26:23

but here we are in mid-2019,

26:26

and you can see everything for yourselves. The development rights were

26:29

bought from the Moscow city government at auction for

26:32

100 million rubles—money that, as we already understand, is

26:34

laughable by Metelsky's standards.

26:36

A trivial sum.

26:37

But a great deal will be built here:

26:39

there will be an ice rink, a renovated movie theater,

26:42

restaurants, and of course commercial

26:45

real estate for shops. And most

26:48

interesting of all, we fly a little away from the site and

26:50

see a brand-new, attractive residential

26:52

complex.

26:53

The Lefort residential complex: two buildings have already been completed,

26:56

a third is being prepared, for a total of 600 apartments.

26:59

It has its own infrastructure, underground

27:02

parking, shops, and landscaped

27:04

grounds. You probably think that I am

27:06

about to say that the Metelskys have

27:08

a luxurious penthouse in this building

27:09

or that the Metelskys bought 10

27:12

apartments in this building.

27:13

No—they own this entire residential

27:15

complex.

27:16

They are the developers; their company built all of this,

27:20

and now they are selling it. Now look:

27:23

the official developer of the residential buildings

27:26

at Lefort is the company

27:27

Inter Flora. According to an announcement

27:30

on the Moscow city government's website, they are also

27:32

the builder of the transport interchange hub.

27:34

of the hub at the metro station, this is an absolutely

27:37

unknown developer. Before this, they had not

27:39

built anything in Moscow at all. So let’s take a look

27:42

carefully at who these developers are, who seem to have come from nowhere

27:45

at all. Until 2015, the company

27:49

was entirely owned by the same

27:51

Lyubov Metelskaya. Then she transferred her share, according to the scheme we mentioned,

27:54

to

27:56

Ivanovsky. The director is a familiar figure to us — a neighbor

27:59

of the Metelskys on the same stairwell landing.

28:00

Kapustin — and let me remind you, he is also the director of

28:03

another Metelsky company, the one building

28:06

a hotel near Paveletskaya, which they

28:08

deliberately bankrupted so they would not have to

28:10

return the investor’s money. We have already

28:12

talked about this. In other words, these are all the same

28:14

old faces — not a single new surname,

28:17

of course. And in the end, our modest Izmailovo

28:20

deputy turned out to be one of the biggest

28:23

property developers in Moscow. Considering

28:25

the number of apartments, their approximate

28:28

value, and the actual figures for apartments already

28:30

sold by Metelsky’s companies,

28:32

they stand to make — attention —

28:35

around 1 billion rubles (about $10–11 million). But that is not

28:38

all. Using the same principle of overlapping

28:41

directors and addresses, we can find even

28:44

more assets.

28:45

Even more businesses. Let’s just do a quick

28:47

blitz run-through. For example, where

28:51

Metelsky owns a 30 percent stake

28:53

in Obukhov car service centers. Yes, Obukhov,

28:56

Obukhov, Vladimir — yes, yes, we are talking specifically about

28:58

the Obukhov centers. All of us have seen them

29:01

a million times, and if someone owns a car

29:03

like a Volvo, they probably get it serviced there. Here

29:05

is a list of seven legal entities connected

29:07

to the Obukhov auto centers, and in each of them

29:09

our old lady Metelskaya has a stake.

29:11

The combined annual turnover of these

29:13

car centers is more than 3 billion

29:16

rubles (about $32 million).

29:17

Let’s continue. Hotels in the Moscow region

29:19

— Foresta Festival Park is also one of their firms,

29:23

registered under Ivanovsky’s name, but managed

29:25

by the younger Metelsky. Don’t stay there

29:27

for vacation, don’t vacation there, don’t get your car repaired

29:30

at Obukhov.

29:31

Don’t use Lefortovo metro station either.

29:33

It is becoming harder and harder to live

29:35

in Moscow without accidentally paying

29:37

Deputy Metelsky. Don’t eat sushi at

29:39

Tanuki restaurants either, because there too

29:42

there is a high chance of handing over your

29:44

money to the Metelsky family. They own a number of these

29:46

restaurants. For example, they own one in

29:48

my southwestern district — actually, two of them,

29:50

located in my electoral district, on

29:52

Profsoyuznaya Street, and another in Zyuzino

29:54

on Balaklavsky Prospekt. And these two restaurants are owned by

29:57

Lyubov A.

29:59

Metelskaya.

30:00

And don’t go steaming away at the Vostochnye Baths in

30:02

Izmailovo either.

30:03

That is Metelsky too. In general, in

30:06

Izmailovo you start to feel somewhat

30:07

uncomfortable, because it creates

30:09

the impression that the Metelsky family

30:12

has decided to buy up absolutely all the

30:13

real estate there, residential and commercial alike. Metelsky

30:16

has a property of almost 500 square meters

30:18

on 15th Parkovaya Street.

30:20

And in this building in Izmailovo, the basement

30:24

and the first floor belong to Verdi Bit and

30:26

Metelskaya. And in my electoral

30:28

district, the Metelskys also own property.

30:30

They bought themselves a huge mansion

30:32

worth nearly 300 million rubles (about $3.2 million)

30:36

near Chistye Prudy (a historic central Moscow neighborhood). I even

30:38

visited it recently. There it is, that very mansion

30:40

that belongs to the Metelsky family.

30:42

Just look at that beauty: three floors, an attic,

30:46

a very nice, comfortable veranda

30:48

upstairs where you can rest and relax,

30:50

an armchair, a little sofa. Right now there is

30:54

an office here, and the land is expensive,

30:56

the rent is expensive, and the profits are very good

30:59

for a modest deputy of the Moscow

31:01

City Duma. Metelsky has done quite well for himself.

31:04

Metelsky, I’m watching you. And

31:06

by the way, let’s talk about where

31:08

Deputy Metelsky and his family live.

31:11

The good news is that they do not

31:13

spend all their time in their Austrian

31:15

palace and do still sometimes show up in Izmailovo.

31:18

But that is where the good news ends,

31:19

because there is a lot of this real estate,

31:22

it is worth insane amounts of money, and of course it is not

31:25

listed in any declarations. Let’s go on. In the same

31:28

building on Pervomayskaya Street that we already

31:30

showed, Verdi Bit and

31:32

Metelskaya own apartment No. 28 — 280

31:36

square meters — and apartment No. 2,

31:38

129 square meters, and one more

31:41

apartment of 173 square meters.

31:44

That apartment belongs to grandmother Lyubov;

31:46

she got it from Pyotr Ivanovsky. And these three

31:50

apartments together form a kind of mega-penthouse

31:53

with an area of 600 square meters. Well yes, that probably

31:57

would not have looked very good in a

31:58

deputy’s declaration. Izmailovo

32:00

voters would hardly have appreciated that.

32:02

Next, the deputy’s son also has

32:05

another apartment in his ownership,

32:07

possibly 115 square meters, on

32:10

Izmailovsky Boulevard.

32:11

From the property extract for it, we learn the name of

32:14

his mother — that is, Deputy Metelsky’s

32:16

apparently former wife. Right here, in the neighboring

32:19

128-square-meter apartment, lives the director

32:23

of most of the deputy’s companies, Kapustin. Let me remind you, he is

32:26

the son of another deputy

32:28

of the Moscow City Duma from United Russia (the ruling political party),

32:30

another fixture in the deputies’ seats. So, as for

32:33

the younger Metelsky’s mother, in

32:35

her ownership there is also a separate

32:37

residential property, again in Izmailovo,

32:39

288 square meters. House neighbors...

32:43

We’re well familiar with Pyotr Ivanovsky, and also

32:46

do you know who Mikhail is? The nephew of none other than

32:49

by the way, the deputy for Koltso, and for

32:51

the Gazprom management board as of last year, and

32:53

of course, two neighboring dachas on Rublyovka (an elite suburban area outside Moscow), in

32:55

the very center of the village of Razdory, and for

32:58

the sake of completeness, let’s add

33:00

an apartment near Patriarch’s Ponds and a house in

33:02

the Kaliningrad region, which also do not appear

33:04

in any declarations. Friends, let’s

33:07

sum it up. Once again, for clarity

33:10

and contrast, let’s pull out the declaration

33:12

of Metelsky: here there is only a deputy’s

33:14

salary and no real estate at all. But

33:16

let’s list what should be there.

33:19

Let’s do it.

33:20

Austria: 4 hotels and a palace, with a total

33:23

value of about 40 million euros

33:26

— that’s almost 2.5 billion rubles.

33:28

Real estate in Moscow: 600

33:31

million rubles. Land for a hotel

33:33

in Moscow: at least 1 billion rubles. On that land

33:36

there are already two buildings; their cadastral

33:38

value is at least another

33:40

And five apartments in the Izmailovo district

33:43

with a total area of 1,000

33:45

square meters, and a value of 200

33:48

million rubles. Two dachas on Rublyovka, three

33:51

houses — 400 million rubles.

33:53

A dacha in Kaliningrad: 25 million rubles.

33:55

And also an apartment near Patriarch’s Ponds: 12

33:58

million rubles. In real estate alone, for

34:00

the leader of Moscow’s United Russia members, we

34:02

counted 5.7 billion

34:04

rubles. And all this real estate, this crook

34:07

is hiding from his voters. And this

34:09

crook and thief has spent 20 years sitting in the Moscow

34:12

City Duma, passing laws that

34:14

you are required to obey. But now

34:18

tell me yourselves: after all this, is it possible

34:21

to give United Russia even a single vote?

34:24

Of course not. They are liars, hypocrites, and thieves. But

34:28

surely United Russia leader

34:31

Metelsky couldn’t have openly built his

34:34

business for years

34:34

in violation of his status as a deputy without

34:37

anyone knowing about it. After all, it is plainly

34:39

spelled out in the rulings of the Moscow

34:42

courts.

34:42

Of course everyone knows. Of course they know. And

34:45

Sobyanin knows, and Putin knows, and absolutely

34:48

all the other United Russia deputies

34:50

know it too. Nevertheless, they elect Metel-

34:54

sky as their leader, and he is running again

34:56

in the elections with his empty declaration. And

34:59

the most terrible thing is that they will be elected again

35:02

if they are not stopped. And personally, you — no one

35:06

else can do it. Each of these

35:09

candidates

35:10

needs your signature to be nominated, right

35:13

now, right this minute. Urgently go

35:16

to the video description — there are instructions there

35:19

on how to sign in support of the person running from

35:21

your district.

35:22

There are 4 days left — hurry. After that,

35:26

sign up for Smart Voting, and

35:28

on the eve of the election, wherever you live — in

35:31

Moscow, St. Petersburg, or another region — we

35:34

will send you

35:36

the name of the person you need to vote for. And on September 8

35:38

you will need to go and

35:40

vote.

35:42

Doing all this is very simple. If we

35:45

do it, we will defeat United Russia, the party

35:49

of crooks and thieves.

Original